Magazine article American Nurse Today

Assessing Nurses' Competency to Achieve Highly Reliable Care

Magazine article American Nurse Today

Assessing Nurses' Competency to Achieve Highly Reliable Care

Article excerpt

A standardized competency assessment process identifies new nurses' individual developmental needs.

AS TENURED NURSES LEAVE the workplace, healthcare organizations are striving to provide additional development and support for the less-experienced new hires who replace them. Assessing their clinical competency and addressing identified gaps without increasing onboarding and orientation costs poses a significant challenge. Ensuring new nurses are adequately prepared to perform their jobs requires assessment of their clinical competency to identify gaps that must be addressed before they take on independent responsibility for patient-care assignments.

Competency assessment is a complex activity with potentially serious implications--not just for the organization but also for the individual being assessed. Thirteen years ago, CHRISTUS Health (based in Irving, Texas) adopted a standardized, reliable process to assess newly hired licensed nurses--the Performance-Based Development System (PBDS). Funded by an internal innovation grant, the process was piloted in a six-hospital region, with results so dramatic that the strategy was quickly adopted throughout the organization.

Stimulus and response

PBDS assessments are multifaceted, with components that focus on such interpersonal skills as conflict management, teamwork, communication, and clinical reasoning. Content and structure of the assessment align with current evidence-based practice. The assessment is structured in terms of stimulus and response.

* Stimulus information may be presented to the learner in any format. The applicant watches a series of 3- to 5-minute video scenarios illustrating patient problems commonly encountered in his or her area of practice. Key aspects of each scenario, such as lab or diagnostic data, are called out and displayed on screen.

* Each video scenario is followed by lead-in questions that trigger a response. The response must identify the primary patient problem, describe interventions to address the problem, explain the rationale for each intervention, and indicate which interventions take highest priority. All responses are free text, or unstructured. (See The value of video scenarios.)

Clinical reasoning skills

Clinical reasoning skills are multifaceted and context-dependent. Nurses draw on their own expertise when making clinical decisions in a dynamic environment where they must consider the personal context as well as the patient's unique healthcare needs and the environment in which the care is being delivered.

During the PBDS process, the applicant's responses are evaluated by a trained rater according to a standardized qualitative analysis procedure. The rater compares the applicant's responses to model answers that include degrees of variation correlating with the nurse's background, experience, and qualifications. The rater shares assessment results, which include an overall performance summary and a developmental action plan, with the applicant's manager. The applicant receives feedback on the results and participates in developing orientation goals.

Orientation action plans may include tutorials to address the applicant's identified knowledge gaps, such as failing to identify patient problems accurately or choosing inappropriate interventions. Preceptors with coaching skills are responsible for engaging the applicant in experiential learning and discussion. Later, a focused PBDS reassessment is conducted to validate that the applicant has achieved developmental goals. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.