Magazine article American Banker

Docket: Credit Union Law May Echo in 2d ABA Suit

Magazine article American Banker

Docket: Credit Union Law May Echo in 2d ABA Suit

Article excerpt

The banking industry is poised to lose a case challenging the ability of community-chartered credit unions to serve huge chunks of a state or region.

The American Bankers Association and the California Bankers Association sued the National Credit Union Administration last October, arguing that the agency broke the law when it gave Point Mugu Federal Credit Union permission to serve all of Ventura County.

The county covers 1,800 square miles of Southern California and houses 670,000 residents-an area bankers argue is so big it cannot be a well- defined community as required by the Federal Credit Union Act.

The case has been on hold for months as Congress debated whether to overturn the AT&T Family Federal Credit Union decision in which the Supreme Court said occupation-based credit unions may not serve employees at multiple companies.

Congress approved that legislation, known as HR 1151, and President Clinton signed it Aug. 7. And while the law eases membership limits on occupation-based credit unions-as opposed to community-based institutions like Point Mugu-there are several provisions that apply to the entire industry.

The most important provision is a grandfather clause that prevents the courts from ordering a credit union to stop serving anyone who is currently within its field of membership.

Legal experts for both the credit union and banking industries said the grandfather clause is so broad that it protects community-based credit unions, such as Point Mugu.

Steven W. Widerman, a trial attorney at the National Credit Union Administration, said the agency has not yet decided how to proceed in the case. "We are going to examine the impact of the Credit Union Membership Access Act on this case and determine the extent it moots the case out," he said.

But other legal experts said the grandfather clause would make it impossible for the banking industry to force the NCUA to rein in Point Mugu or similar credit unions. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.