Magazine article The Christian Century

LIVING BY the Word: Reflections on the Lectionary

Magazine article The Christian Century

LIVING BY the Word: Reflections on the Lectionary

Article excerpt

December 31, First Sunday after Christmas Day

Luke 2:22-40

SEMINARIANS MUST roll their eyes at how often I ask them to fill in the blank: "Jesus was a ..."


"And Peter was a ..."

"Jew." And Mary, and Paul. This simple point--that the New Testament's key figures all lived and died as Jews--is now taken for granted in theological education. The various movements we now identify with earliest Christianity all thrived within the orbit of ancient Judaism. Participants read Jewish scriptures, argued over the details of daily living as Jews, and worshiped the one they believed to be the Messiah of Israel.

Fifty years ago, these assumptions could not be taken for granted. Christian scholars emphasized how Jesus differed from his Jewish environment and debated Paul's criticisms of his own religion. They sought explanations for the "parting of the ways." Reclaiming the Jewish identity of Jesus is one of the great changes in biblical scholarship over the past few decades.

We encounter Luke 2:22-40 during the Christmas season but after the story of Jesus' birth. No angels or shepherds here. Certainly no Magi or malevolent Herod--Luke's infancy account shares little with Matthew's, apart from the names of Jesus' parents. Luke's theological perspective is distinctive as well. Jesus' birth brings salvation to all people, a salvation profoundly grounded in the hopes of Israel. Our trouble happens precisely here: How does Israel's good news relate to good news for the gentiles?

Luke's introduction insists upon Jesus as a child of Israel. The narrative begins with his relatives Zechariah and Elizabeth, who "blamelessly" observe "all the commandments and regulations of the Lord" (1:6). Elizabeth's pregnancy recalls Sarah's: both previously childless, they conceived when they were "getting on in years" (1:7). When Gabriel informs Mary of her impending pregnancy, he promises that Jesus will sit on David's throne and rule over Jacob's house--that is, over Israel (1:32-33). Mary and Zechariah both break into song, Mary celebrating God's help to Israel (1:54) and Zechariah Israel's redemption from its enemies (1:68-74).

So it comes as no surprise that Jesus' parents would circumcise their infant son and later present him in the temple "according to the law of Moses." Preachers have long noted the modest sacrifice Joseph and Mary bring: if one cannot afford a sheep, a pair of turtledoves or pigeons will do (Lev. 5:11, 12:8). Jesus' parents are too poor to offer a sheep. Luke shows no sentimentality toward Jesus' poverty, however, having suggested already that through Jesus God will fill the hungry with good things and send the rich away empty (1:53). Whatever we may find in our Christmas carols, Jesus' poverty is not to be romanticized. Mary and Joseph appear together at the temple as faithful Israelites.

Interpreters have long noted Luke's tendency to pair a story about a man with another about a woman, often giving the man more detailed treatment. Consider the centurion and the widow (7:1-14), or the parables of the shepherd who loses a sheep and the woman who loses a coin (15:3-10). (Mary, of course, gets extensive treatment in Luke.)

Enter Simeon and Anna. Luke suggests both are far along in years. Anna is 84, widowed after a marriage of only seven years. Ancient life expectancies being what they were, perhaps she feels only slightly cheated. But she has been on her own a very long time. Luke doesn't give Simeon's age, but he has been waiting for Israel's consolation, informed by the Holy Spirit that he will see the Messiah before he dies. "Now you are dismissing your servant in peace," he says in his prayer, indicating the imminence of his death. Anna does not receive a speaking part. But the two are united in their old age, their piety, and their hope. Simeon awaits Israel's comfort, while Anna looks for Jerusalem's redemption. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.