Magazine article American Journalism Review

Cartoonists See More Caution in Editing

Magazine article American Journalism Review

Cartoonists See More Caution in Editing

Article excerpt

They add high readership amid circulation worries.

Is a noose tightening around editorial cartoonists? Are they being roped in by cautious big-company ownership?

Cartoonists, being creative types, are natural sufferers. They probably always thought they were up against it.

But the collective opinion of some savvy name-brand cartoonists recently assembled at the American Press Institute was that the fear of offending prevails more frequently today. The same concern has been heard at other meetings around the big table at API.

When you mix 17 cartoonists with half a dozen editors and a couple of publishers, drop in a spoonful of fresh ideas and stir with a pinch of irony and a dash of bitters, you get "Drawing Fire: The State of Political Cartooning."

This was API's annual J. Montgomery Curtis Memorial Seminar. (Participants' expenses were paid.)

The venerable Paul Conrad lamented that newspapers had been "dumbing down," with bad consequences for cartoonists. Pat Oliphant predicted more "dumbing" ahead.

The cartoonists talked about the negative aspects of syndication. Every cartoonist, probably, wants the biggest possible audience. Syndication makes you famous. But it also makes you do less with the territory where you could do the most good: your home state and city. You choose a topic that will appeal to as many newspapers as possible.

Some of the best in the business routinely do only one local cartoon a week, some two. (Local cartoons are less likely to win prizes.)

Editors and publishers who want more than that risk losing good cartoonists to other papers that will not require it. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.