Magazine article American Libraries

Restricting Books Behind Bars: Books-to-Prisoners Groups Face Roadblocks

Magazine article American Libraries

Restricting Books Behind Bars: Books-to-Prisoners Groups Face Roadblocks

Article excerpt

Backlash was swift when it was publicized in January that the New York State Department of Corrections and Community Supervision (DOCCS) had begun requiring that packages to prisoners come from a handful of state-approved vendors only.

While the package contents were not limited to books, the proposed change hampered books-to-prisoners organizations in their mission to provide reading material to the incarcerated. A large part of the controversy stemmed from the initial five vendors' limited selection of fewer than 100 books, many of which were coloring or puzzle books. Stories in The New York Times and elsewhere exposed the decision, prompting Gov. Andrew Cuomo to reverse the policy.

That rapid change in response to public scrutiny mirrored one that took place in New Jersey a few days prior to Cuomo's decision. The New Jersey Department of Corrections had banned prisoners from reading Michelle Alexander's 2010 book The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness, which explores the US prison system and the incarceration of African Americans. The decision to lift the book ban came within hours of the American Civil Liberties Union of New Jersey sending a letter to the department of corrections demanding it remove the restriction.

On May 3 the US Bureau of Prisons made a similar move when it rescinded a policy that banned direct delivery of books from publishers, book clubs, and bookstores to inmates in federal prisons.

Ben Schatz, a public defender in New York City who runs a program called Books Beyond Bars, says efforts to block books-to-prisons groups is "enormously frustrating."

"This is not an attempt to get The Anarchist Cookbook to prisoners," he says. "It's largely people who want to learn a skill or trade."

Newspaper headlines and letters from attorneys threatening legal action often get results, but the challenge of getting reading material to prisoners is widespread and recurring--once one problem is fixed in one state, the issue often emerges in another.

Organizations in smaller states often find little recourse when individual prisons and prison systems decide to shut them out. These groups must rely instead on negotiating with corrections departments.

American Libraries found books-to-prisoners organizations in Arizona and Mississippi that also have recently dealt with policy changes at corrections departments that they say have put restrictions on their programs. And though the immediate battle in places like New York appears over, advocates there are waiting for the next move by DOCCS. They argue that prisoners who are allowed to read are less likely to end up back behind bars ( pubs/research_reports/RR266.html), and many are requesting reading materials--some commonly requested books are dictionaries and books on learning a trade and how to start a business--to prepare themselves for life after release.

Books-to-prisoners groups in New York lauded Cuomo's decision to reverse the recent DOCCS policy there, but Amy Peterson, of the NYC Books Through Bars collective, says her group is waiting to see if the department revises the original policy.

In a January 9, 2018, story in The New Yorker, DOCCS Acting Commissioner Anthony J. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.