Magazine article American Banker

Small Iowa Bank Defeated in Name-Confusion Suit

Magazine article American Banker

Small Iowa Bank Defeated in Name-Confusion Suit

Article excerpt

An Iowa community bank has lost its long-running fight to force a huge competitor to use another name.

The Iowa Supreme Court ruled that Commercial Federal Bank of Omaha could keep using its name in Carroll, Iowa, even though some customers and townspeople confused it with Commercial Savings Bank, a $75 million-asset community bank based there.

Commercial Savings sued the subsidiary of $11 billion-asset Commercial Federal Corp. in 1996 after the company acquired Hawkeye Federal Savings Bank in Carroll and changed Hawkeye's name to Commercial Federal.

In its lawsuit, Commercial Savings said customers and others in Carroll often confused the two institutions.

Commercial Savings said that, for example, one Commercial Federal customer called Commercial Savings with a complaint about her account; another person

visited a Commercial Savings office to inquire about rates Commercial Federal advertised in a newspaper.

Telephone callers often mixed up the two banks, and the U.S. Postal Service delivered Commercial Federal's mail to Commercial Savings in the weeks after the merger, court documents show.

Seeking to eliminate confusion, Commercial Savings asked the Iowa courts to force Commercial Federal to use another name in Commercial Savings' eight-county market area.

But the Iowa Supreme Court upheld a lower court's ruling in favor of Commercial Federal. The big bank may keep its name because it is unlikely that "customers of Commercial Savings will be so confused that they will inadvertently do their banking business with Commercial Federal," Chief Justice Arthur McGiverin wrote. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.