Magazine article Editor & Publisher

Facebook Could Actually Benefit from a Little Regulation

Magazine article Editor & Publisher

Facebook Could Actually Benefit from a Little Regulation

Article excerpt

On March 22, five days after the Cambridge Analytica scandal broke, Mark Zuckerberg came up with a weird statement regarding the prospect of regulation. "I actually am not sure we shouldn't be regulated," he said in typical Zuck parlance.

Why the hell would Facebook's lider maximo welcome the intrusion of a regulator?

Two reasons: it could help his business in the long run, and by the time any regulation takes effect, Facebook will have consolidated even further its already immense power.

Let's draw a parallel with the banking industry. This sector is one of the most regulated in the world. It's an industry that is virtually impregnable, despite its long standing shortcomings. Banks are the least customer-friendly businesses you can imagine; whether you are a business or an individual, you pay an awful lot of commissions and fees for mediocre service. Even worse, banks kindly cooperate with their respective national tax systems, providing the government with all sorts of information, a practice that any privacy lawyer would love to challenge.

Banks have made of regulation the best guarantee for the perpetuation of their mediocrity. The only sector I see coming close in terms of regulation is the airlines industry, which at least has the excuse of passenger safety.

As a result, no one is willing to enter the banking sector. This better preserves the status quo; in the U.S. alone a third of bank customers said they would switch if Google, Amazon or Facebook offer banking services.

This "protection by regulation" is an inspirational example for Facebook. The global social network might experience a slight pain of having regulators curb the most abusive part of its business, but in the end the benefits will largely outweigh the hurdles.

Facebook has very little to fear from regulators, whether in the United States or in Europe. In countries in Southeast Asia, and soon in Sub-Saharan Africa, where Facebook aims to embody the internet, it doesn't have to worry at all about oversight. It can still enjoy the position of a Big Tobacco, willing to create new pools of addicts.

In Washington, Facebook is now a strong player, on par with its two giant pals, Amazon and Google. Together, they spend nearly as much on influence lawmakers as Boeing, the primary U.S. defense contractor.

Big Tech "owns" a large chunk of the political spectrum, starting with the Democratic establishment, as noted recently by The Intercept: "Democrats have long-standing and numerous ties to the tech community. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.