Magazine article The Christian Century

Inauthentic but Valid

Magazine article The Christian Century

Inauthentic but Valid

Article excerpt

IN LIES ACROSS AMERICA: What Our Historic Sites Get Wrong James w. Loewen tells us that he, encountered a marker at the Little Bighorn River battlefield in Montana dedicated to U.S. Army soldiers killed "while clearing the district ... of hostile Indians." He also studied markers dedicated to "patriots" who were actually slave traders or Klansmen racists. Markers long got the Mormon Meadows

Massacre dead wrong, intentionally. (The Latter-day Saints have since rectified that.)

It occurs to me that we Christian visitors to holy places--Santiago de Compostela, Loretto and the like--also need to deal with lies and fibs. We Protestants could stand some scrubbing of that famed ink stain in Wittenberg Castle, where Martin Luther did/didn't throw ink at Satan.

Pilgrimages to the Holy Land sharpen the issue. Almost all revered sites first got identified and connected with presumed biblical-era happenings three or four centuries after the event--as far as we are from the Plymouth Colony pilgrims.

Space permits only one illustration. During a visit to the Holy Land our group was gathered in a cave near Bethlehem. Our Israel-credentialed guide played along with what has to be a fib. "Do you realize you are standing in the very cave where the three Magi stayed on the way to Bethlehem?"

Don't rank me with the historical-critical folk who think nothing happened back then unless the Jesus Seminar votes that it did. Think of me as an ordinary historian and critic who willingly suspends some measure of disbelief to get a sense of empathy for various pasts, including the biblical, and to connect them with various presents, including both scholarship and piety. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.