Magazine article Artforum International

Case Dismissed

Magazine article Artforum International

Case Dismissed

Article excerpt

BACK IN 1990, the obscenity charges brought against the Cincinnati Contemporary Arts Center and its director, Dennis Barrie, sent shock waves through the art world. The fact that Barrie faced a possible prison term gave pause to art professionals everywhere. The occasion for the criminal proceedings was an exhibition that the Arts Center had rented from the University of Pennsylvania's Institute of Contemporary Art. Titled "The Perfect Moment," the show was a survey of Robert Mapplethorpe's photographs first mounted in Philadelphia in 1988. By the time the exhibition reached Cincinnati, the artist had been dead a year, and the show had already traveled to Chicago, Washington, DC, Hartford, and Berkeley, with its final destination scheduled in Boston.

The Washington stop, however, marked the onset of the court battle that would ultimately erupt in Ohio. "The Perfect Moment" had been scheduled for the Corcoran Gallery of Art, but when Jesse Helms and the Religious Right mounted an all-out blitz against the exhibition, the Corcoran caved and canceled the show. While the Washington Project for the Arts quickly stepped into the fray to provide an alternate venue, Helms and his flying monkeys had already declared war and were headed for a battlefield in the American heartland.

Dirty Pictures, which airs throughout June on Showtime, tells the story of how the flying monkeys almost stole the light of reason. Director Frank Pierson's docudrama is an OK television movie. The emphasis is on a seemingly decent man and his attractive family (loyal wife, scrappy sons) fighting the forces of bigotry and censorship. The facts are clearly presented, and Mapplethorpe's photographs generously punctuate the trial sequences as evidence for the rather surreal testimony introduced by both accusers and accused. What's strange, though, is how remote it all seems. It's as if Dirty Pictures wants to be Inherit the Wind but lacks that drama's moral gravity.

A big part of the problem with the film is that Mapplethorpe's photographs are never convincingly argued as art, so the core of the drama is very much a formal essay on First Amendment rights. There's so little passionate engagement with Mapplethorpe's artistry that Dirty Pictures feels a bit soulless. Sure, moral fascists still slither like rattlesnakes on warm rocks across the editorial pages of all our hometown newspapers, waiting to strike. And if anything, censorship has grown even more overtly cynical, as exemplified by Mayor Rudolph Giuliani's self-serving attack on Chris Ofili and the Brooklyn Museum of Art. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.