Magazine article The American Prospect

Who Governs?

Magazine article The American Prospect

Who Governs?

Article excerpt

Whoever wins, this will be the election that was stolen. Republicans have played the nastier hardball, throwing around phrases like coup d'etat, questioning the very legitimacy of courts to decide questions of law, intimidating vote counters, and shamelessly using election officials as partisan hacks. Thus energized, they are certain that George W. Bush truly won and Al Gore would be a usurper.

For his part, the vice president has a fair case that, if voters' true intent can be measured, Florida is his. Gore also won the popular vote by more than 300,000. In our system, that doesn't count, but it does lend legitimacy. If Gore is denied the presidency, it will be because (1) the media created the premature sense that Bush was the rightful winner, (2) the Bush campaign effectively ran the clock on Gore, and (3) there was no clean way for the courts or anyone else to render a definitive ruling.

But whoever takes office January 20, the opposition will insist that the wrong president was inaugurated. A fine mess.

The immediate consequences will be more serious for Democrats and liberals than for the republic and Republicans. If Bush takes office, having run one of the dirtiest overtime periods in memory, he will revert to his campaign pretense as bipartisan healer. He will cultivate nominal Democrats like Senator John Breaux of Louisiana, the Blue Dog caucus, and New Democrats soft on such Republican favorites as vouchers and privatization. With their collaboration, Bush could soon look like a centrist Dwight Eisenhower or, worse, a Republican Bill Clinton. The press, obsessed with the idea that the public is sick of partisan squabbling, will fall for it. The only thing that can prevent this outcome is Bush's own sheer stupidity or a serious economic or foreign-policy crisis. But Ronald Reagan, if anything, was an even dimmer bulb, and Jim Baker and company made him just glow. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.