Magazine article Clinical Psychiatry News

Challenges of Genetic Testing

Magazine article Clinical Psychiatry News

Challenges of Genetic Testing

Article excerpt

We need to think about some of the ethical issues of genetic testing today since regular routine clinical testing does not appear to be very far in the future.

First we need to consider the difference between testing for somatic cell mutations and germline mutations, because the issues are different.

With somatic cell mutation testing, the general ethical concerns of regular clinical tests apply, and there really are no special unique "genetic" issues, This needs emphasis because, at least in oncology, this will constitute the vast majority of testing. These tests do not raise special ethical concerns that we associate with genetics because they have no reproductive or family implications. They are really like many other prognostic tests that we use, like prostate specific antigen. Our concerns about them relate to the issues of analytic validity clinical validity and utility

The public and physicians must be educated to see that somatic cell information does not have the worrisome implications that they associate with the term "genetic tests."

Germline mutation tests are the genetic tests that have the worrisome features. The worrisome features are related to three major characteristics: the probabilistic nature of the information, another way of saying uncertainty; the familial implications, the fact that information you find has implications for other members of the family; and the reproductive implications, the potential of passing on the genes to one's children.

These features are worrisome because they increase the potential harms. By and large, we are talking about psychological harms, harms to families, and social harms.

Psychological harms really arise from uncertainty, confusion, and anxiety about the probabilistic nature of the information. The test may not be 100% reliable, and even if the test is reliable, it usually won't give you a "yes, you are going to get this cancer" or "no, you are not going to get this cancer" type of answer. It says you are at increased risk for developing this type of cancer.

The familial harms result from the inheritable nature of germline mutations, mixed in with the fact that there are all these complex family dynamics.

Social harms are ones that come from stigmatization, discrimination, and harms that come from identifying certain genetic patterns with certain groups. Information about germline mutations can affect things beyond just the denial of health insurance. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.