Magazine article Insight on the News

Campaign Finance Is Not the Reform We Need

Magazine article Insight on the News

Campaign Finance Is Not the Reform We Need

Article excerpt

The U.S. House of Representatives, in reckless disregard of the Constitution when it passed "campaign-finance-reform" legislation, has demonstrated dramatically why we need real political reform. The First Amendment to the Constitution begins "Congress shall make no law" on several subjects, including any law "abridging freedom of speech."

Yet here was the House working into the wee hours of the morning to flat out prohibit various kinds of political speech within 30 and/or 60 days of an election. Just what part of "Congress shall make no law" do lawmakers not understand?

Sadly, they do understand. But the Constitution is no stronger than the willingness to defend it. If the voting public easily is stampeded into thinking that there is a desperate need for campaign-finance reform, then defense of the Constitution may depend on whether the White House is willing to take the heat for opposing a popular measure during an election year.

The last line of defense for the Constitution is the Supreme Court, but this particular set of justices too often splits the baby instead of taking a stand on principle. We don't need nine more clever politicians across the street from Congress, but that is what we have had.

Why is campaign-finance reform so popular, and with whom? This is not something that the public is demanding. Polls repeatedly show little or no public urgency about the matter.

Those most enthusiastic about campaign-finance reform are the media and elected officials, backed up by various other special interests that stand to gain. What campaign-finance reform restricts are public expressions of alternative sources of information and viewpoints besides those which dominate the media. Naturally, the media would love to have a monopoly, since none of these laws restricts what the media can say or when they can say it.

Elected officials also would like to see their competition stifled. Campaign-finance reform laws do not restrict what incumbents can say or do in their official capacities, which not only makes "news" but does it free of charge -- or at the taxpayers' expense, which amounts to the same thing.

Members of Congress can lie through their teeth on television right on up to, and including, Election Day. But if you correct or challenge what they say with paid ads at the forbidden times, you will be violating federal law. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.