Magazine article Reason

Editor's Note

Magazine article Reason

Editor's Note

Article excerpt

IF THEY SURVIVE...will we?

That was the spooky come-on for The Boys From Brazil, the popular 1978 movie that served as many people's introduction to cloning and other forms of genetic manipulation. What a downbeat primer: Based on the Ira Levin novel, the plot revolved around Josef Mengele, then the most notorious at-large war criminal from World War II, and an attempt to create a Fourth Reich by genetically engineering a new Hitler.

The year 1978 showcased another biologically loaded debut, one that momentarily inspired far more fear and panic than The Boys From Brazil: the birth of Louise Brown as the world's first "test-tube baby." "Is it dehumanizing," asked Time, "a step that is to be condemned because it puts the moment of creation outside the body into a mechanical environment?"

A quarter of a century later, The Boys From Brazil surfaces occasionally on late-night TV, an over-the-top relic of apocalyptic '70s culture. In vitro fertilization, the process through which Louise Brown was conceived, is common enough that it no longer merits much discussion, let alone societal anxiety.

But as human cloning and a host of other related technologies edge closer to becoming reality, arguments over their desirability, implications, and legal status are only getting started. This is serious stuff: Not only do these procedures hold forth the greatest promise for the improvement of human life in the coming decades, but they are on the verge of being prohibited, at least in the United States.

Last year the House of Representatives passed a comprehensive ban on human cloning, including therapeutic cloning aimed at creating embryonic stem cells that might one day help cure Alzheimer's disease, diabetes, and many other illnesses. As I write this, President George W. Bush is pushing the Senate to pass the ban, which he will happily sign into law. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.