Magazine article Black Issues in Higher Education

Student Groups Criticize Election Reform Legislation; College Students Would Be Disproportionately Affected by Bill's Provisions

Magazine article Black Issues in Higher Education

Student Groups Criticize Election Reform Legislation; College Students Would Be Disproportionately Affected by Bill's Provisions

Article excerpt

A legislative plan to curb voting irregularities may have unintended consequences for college students wishing to cast ballots, student groups and other critics say.

A Senate-approved bill would require first-time voters to present photo identification cards showing their names and addresses. Among those most affected by the change may be college students, who switch addresses frequently and may move from a two-year to four-year college, changes that would require them to obtain new cards.

"Students are disproportionately first-time voters and would be severely disenfranchised by the ID provision," says Julia Beatty, president of the U.S. Student Association, a student-led organization in Washington. In effect, she says, it "systematically shuts out hundreds of thousands of student voters" who care deeply about their communities.

The ID provision has support in both the House and Senate, which want to curb voter fraud and abuse following the contentious 2000 presidential election. While a photo ID for first-time voters may curb some fraud, it could hurt other groups, including the disabled as well as absentee voters.

"We must ensure that we are making voting easier for qualified Americans, not more cumbersome," says Adam Lioz of the U.S. PIRG Democracy project. Moreover, localities could curb fraud just as easily by using verification measures that do not require new voters to obtain a picture ID.

As an alternative to a photo ID, the bill before Congress would allow individuals to bring a utility bill or other household bill to the voting booth as proof of identity and local residence. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.