Magazine article Artforum International

Manifesta 4. (Reviews)

Magazine article Artforum International

Manifesta 4. (Reviews)

Article excerpt

VARIOUS VENUES, FRANKFURT

The 2000 edition of Manifesta, Europe's roving biennial of young art, took place in the shadow of NATO'S 1999 bombing of Serbia and the collapse of the Yugoslav Republic. The city of Ljubljana, located at a historical crossroads between East and West, offered a resonant setting for what was to be a roughly hewn but timely exhibition memorable for its uncompromising foregrounding of the documentary mode and for introducing the work of a number of remarkable new artists. This year Manifesta was in Frankfurt, in the capitalist heartland of Western Europe. It was hard to imagine the city firing either the soul or the imagination, and certainly the curators of Manifesta 4 seem to have struggled to find inspiration. Frankfurt (aka Bankfurt) is the financial and transportation hub of mainland Europe, a point of passage for people, money, and things. It's a city that stands for the dream of European political and economic unification: comfortable, prosperous, and--with the exception of its leviathan airport and that giant sculpture of a Euro you run into near the Hauptbahnhof--generally lacking in distinguishing features. Monetary convergence and the enlargement of the community to the east have been the dominant issues in European politics this past year, and Manifesta 4, polite, thoughtful, and conscientiously researched, seemed to reflect a Europe that has passed from violent disintegration to peaceable integration.

Although the pan-European curatorial team--Iara Boubnova from Sofia, Nuria Enguita Mayo from Barcelona, Stephanie Moisdon Trembley from Paris--spoke of a "reflexive project, based on doubt, conflict and confrontation," the experience of the exhibition was one singularly lacking in passion. Despite its wide geographic sweep--with artists hailing from Bilbao to Brussels to Bosnia--it felt as homogeneous as the dream of Euroland itself: a federal exhibition based on agreement rather than polemic. There were plenty of young artists niggling away at the edges of capitalist order by way of pseudocorporations and activist collectives but little work, for example, that reflected on Europe's smoldering tensions, such as the increasing mobility of asylum seekers and a concomitant rise in xenophobic politics in Western Europe.

Manifesta has always been laudable in its aim to provide a more experimental alternative to the proliferating international biennials, with their predictably global rosters of big-name artists. It has never tried to be a mini-Documenta, stressing instead process over spectacle, discursivity over definition, the formation of cultural networks over curatorial mandate. And yet this edition highlighted more than any other the fundamental problem of trying to undo the biennial format while ultimately operating within the same paradigm. A little like Zlatan Filipovic's video ReStart, 2000, in which the artist systematically dismantles and reassembles a laptop computer, Manifesta 4 felt like a biennial taken apart, put back together, and finally looking exactly the same but with a few loose parts rattling around inside.

There is a fine line, after all, between forging new kinds of noninstitutional relationships among artists, curators, and the public and just substituting a different type of bureaucratic apparatus. Much was made of the transparency of the way participants were selected, and French artist Mathieu Mercier designed a huge archive to house all the paperwork gathered in the course of meetings with some one thousand artists. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.