Magazine article Public Finance

The Shape of Places to Come

Magazine article Public Finance

The Shape of Places to Come

Article excerpt

Could local authorities be about to regain a proper role in the governance of the NHS? The juxtaposition of last week's local government white paper and the Public Finance/Deloitte health round table begs a fascinating question about the future control of Britain's health provision. It is just possible the government has put in place the first building block of a renewed local democratic influence over the NHS.

Although 'joined-up government' has become something of a cliché, the notion that local schools, health provision, social services, the police and the criminal justice system should work together is plain common sense. Sir Michael Lyons' concept of 'place shaping' itself risks becoming over-used, but again he is right to point out that only elected local government has the legitimacy to bring the full range of local services together to deliver seamless and consistent public provision.

The new white paper is clear that Local Strategic Partnerships, using resources brought together within Local Area Agreements, are to be strengthened and made more effective. Non-local government partners, including health trusts, will be required to take part.

Although Local Government Secretary Ruth Kelly's document didn't quite make the point explicitly, Whitehall's weak and silo-dominated approach to public service provision can only be made rational at the local level. The Department of Health cannot be forced to work consistently with, say the Home Office. But clever local officials can, by force of argument and cunning, get local health providers and the police to bend their priorities towards greater consistency within their area.

Of course, there are many problems with LSPs and LAAs, not the least the limit to their political accountability. A semi-official partnership of different public bodies is an awkward institution for the public to understand or to hold to account. Having said that, many NHS bodies are only faintly accessible to the electorate, answering to ministers and Parliament.

The white paper makes it clear that council leaders and portfolioholders must provide democratic legitimacy, though others may chair the LSP. An effective local authority will become first among eguals within the LSP and should, under the white paper proposals, be able to create a bridgehead into the budgets of a number of services. In the short term, the government does not plan to put all public service budgets into the LAA, but in the longer term, anything is surely possible.

The PF round table revealed exasperation at the complex and erratic policy signals given to local health bodies. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.