Magazine article The Spectator

Swagger, Colour and Dash

Magazine article The Spectator

Swagger, Colour and Dash

Article excerpt


Hutchinson, L (English pound)25, pp. 724, ISBN 0091794218

AN. Wilson claims that he can imagine nothing more agreeable than the life of a country parson, `born in the 1830s with the genetic inheritance of strong teeth'. The Victorians are still vivid to him: from his 1950s childhood, he can recall the last vestiges of their way of life - gas-lit station waiting-rooms, cream jugs covered with beaded cloths - and memories of actual survivors, too. `When I went up to Oxford in 1969,' he tells us in the introduction, `there were at least two pair of spinster sisters, the Misses Butler and Deneke, who could remember tea parties with Lewis Carroll.' (Even though I'm five years younger than Wilson, I can cap that - Frances Partridge, still happily with us, told me that she could remember Henry James flinging her playfully into the air; and I once met a man whose gardener had been a powder-monkey at the battle of Trafalgar.)

It is this immediate, imaginative link with the 19th century which makes Wilson's synoptic survey of the era so lively and engaging. Not one of its 620 pages of text is dull or vaporous. Wilson may not be the most subtle or elegant of stylists, but his prose is unfailingly lucid and witty. He is never pretentious, he has the gifts of clarity and wit, informed by a breadth of erudition, a quickly inflamed moral fervour and an intense sense of identification with his grandfathers' and great-grandfathers' generations. He went to Rugby and still worries about the absence of God. He is, in other words, more than a bit of a Victorian himself.

Yet his bravado in this undertaking has perhaps been excessive. The book doesn't confine itself in any respect, and the result is not so much baggy as bursting at the seams. It has `swollen to proportions which appal its author,' he admits in the preface.

In structure it is neither a series of cynical Stracheyan personality sketches, nor a concentrated `Portrait of an Age,' along the lines of G. M. Young's matchless Olympian essay of 1936. Political, military, social, cultural and economic in scope, it rushes with hectic energy from the burning of the old Houses of Parliament in 1834 to the Queen's funeral at Osborne in 1901. This omnium gatherum approach is inevitably superficial - nobody and nothing is lingered over for more than a few pages.

Skating over thin ice with such speed and elan, Wilson doesn't always see the wood for the trees. He dives into his sources like a gannet, and moves on, zigzagging crazily: from Chartism he digresses to Jamaica, the Irish famine leads him to Ruskin, Darwin to divorce. Dipped into at bedtime, the effect must be exhilarating.

Absorbed continuously, from cover to cover, the constant veering and shearing may make the reader feel slightly queasy.

Wilson offers no real thesis to provide any sort of architectural foundation, but the book see-saws between two perspectives on the Victorian achievement. On the one hand, it excoriates 'a ruthless, grabbing, competitive male-dominated society, stamping on its victims and discarding its weaker members with all the devastating relentlessness of mutant species in Darwin's vision of nature itself ; on the other, it admires `the redeeming Victorian capacity for self-criticism and reform', articulated by a wealth and variety of `dissentient voices'.

Wilson feels no romantic exultation at the thought of the empire, and takes an unremittingly grim view of British treatment of the Irish question. Blame for the Indian mutiny, Gordon at Khartoum, the Zulu and Boer wars is laid squarely at the door of the powers at Westminster. The scramble for Africa is, from his perspective, motivated entirely by greed, sprinkled with some Biblebashing. His historical sympathies fail him when he comes to questions of race, and he finds `the confidence with which white Europeans assumed racial superiority over the African or the Indian' to be `one of the most shocking aspects of the Victorian sensibility'. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.