Magazine article The Spectator

Want a Big Bonus? Get Yourself a Public Sector Job

Magazine article The Spectator

Want a Big Bonus? Get Yourself a Public Sector Job

Article excerpt

Imagine for a moment that you are a banker in one of the bailed-out banks. You have seen a few of your colleagues disappear into the lift with a bin bag and every time you wander past a pub you have had to endure the thought that there may be drinkers inside demanding you be sentenced to cruel and more unusual punishments. Yet, for all the angst of the past year, you may be just beginning to wonder: will life in the public sector really be so bad after all?

Ministers may bark at the size of your salary and bonuses, but it is has taken a week of national outrage for them to force action on bonuses out of the Royal Bank of Scotland, and even then many will receive them, or will receive salary increases to compensate for the loss of a bonus. The most telling comment to come from the government was not from a minister, however, but from an unnamed Treasury official who told the Daily Mail that some bonuses couldn't be cut because 'it wouldn't stand up in the European Court if Human Rights. We can't come along and say we're legislating to override someone's employment rights.' Oh, and then there was Harriet Harman's complaint that female bankers are receiving bonuses that are too small.

Thank heavens for the public sector, where the pay is still great but where you can enjoy security too. You think you couldn't find a more extravagant bonus culture and an even more absurd system for rewarding failure than exists at the banks? Just look at the public sector. In fact, let's start by looking at the public sector employee who was charged with the task of monitoring the banks to ensure they didn't get into trouble. That man was Clive Briault, managing director of retail at the Financial Services Authority.

Having failed completely to detect anything wrong at Northern Rock, he resigned last April. That is as it should be, except that far from falling on his sword, Mr Briault appears to have been allowed to run off with it and melt it down and use the silver to augment his pension. The FSA's annual report reveals that he left with £356,452 of compensation for lost salary and bonuses, £36,000 of pension contributions and £202,500 for 'compensation for loss of office'.

Hang on, let's just get this right. An employee resigns because he failed to do the job demanded of him -- and he still gets paid a bonus, plus compensation for suffering the ignominy of having to resign. His case is not a one-off. Take Rose Gibb, who left her £150,000-a-year job as chief executive of the Maidstone and Tunbridge Wells NHS Trust just before the publication of a critical report by the Healthcare Commission into an outbreak of Clostridium difficile in which 345 patients died. To see her on her way, the Trust offered her a £250,000 severance package. Only £75,000 of this was pay in lieu of her notice: the other £174,573 was, as with Mr Briault, 'compensation for loss of office'.

Although, after an outcry, the Health Secretary, Alan Johnson, tried to block the payout, he later backed down and allowed Ms Gibb her £75,000 in lieu of notice. Even so, she has gone to the High Court to claim the full whack.

What kind of an employment contract is it that ends up paying you more for being booted out for failing than it would have done had you worked out your notice? The sort of employment contract which is all too common in the public sector, that's what. The government no longer offers jobs for life; it now just offers payment for life, whether you manage to hold on to your job or not.

Senior public sector workers did extraordinarily well out of the boom years. They negotiated themselves huge salary rises on the basis of comparisons with the private sector. They started calling themselves directors and chief executives instead of town clerks and under-secretaries. They eagerly adopted the concept of guaranteed bonuses and big pay-offs. But with private sector workers losing their jobs fast, or suffering cuts in salary, public sector workers suddenly see less need to ape the ways of the private sector. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.