Magazine article Washington Report on Middle East Affairs

Federal Court of Canada to Decide Landmark Case on Jewish Charity

Magazine article Washington Report on Middle East Affairs

Federal Court of Canada to Decide Landmark Case on Jewish Charity

Article excerpt


Members of the Canadian Jewish community are anxiously awaiting a decision by the Federal Court of Canada regarding a tax appeal launched by a Jewish charity. The decision could mean that the Canadian Magen David Adom for Israel (CMDA) loses its charitable status for financing activities beyond Israel's pre-1967 boundaries, in contravention of Canadian policy.

Jewish settlements in the West Bank, Gaza Strip and East Jerusalem are considered 11 contrary to international law and unhelpful to the peace process," according to the Canada Customs and Revenue Agency (CCRA). Canada's Department of External Affairs considers the settlements an obstacle to peace in the Middle East.

About two years ago, the CCRA notified the CMDA that its charity registration was being revoked for operating in the occupied territories. Canadian tax laws permit donors to claim a tax deduction for contributions to registered charities. Provisions of the Income Tax Act allow donors to write off part of their charitable contributions and thereby reduce their taxable income by as much as 20 percent.

The deduction provisions of the Income Tax Act, aimed at encouraging private contributions to charities, appear to have been used quite successfully by supporters of Israeli settlement activity, considered illegal under international law. According to the Israeli human rights group B'Tselem, the settler population in the West Bank (including East Jerusalem) numbers 380,000. In its report Land Grab, released earlier this year, the rights group also noted that, between 1993 and 2000, the number of settlers in the West Bank increased almost 100 percent.

Under Canadian law, it is not illegal to send money to Israeli settlements. It is unlawful, however, to claim a charitable tax deduction for the contribution, which is exactly what many CMDA contributors are doing. A 1997 investigative report by the Toronto Star revealed that a number of Jewish organizations were using their charitable status to issue receipts for such contributions. Despite the negative publicity raised by the story and promises by the government to act, the practice still appears to be widespread.

In 1997 the government revoked the charitable status of the Toronto Zionist Council after it was revealed that the Council channeled funds to the settlements. Unlike the Council, however, the CMDA appealed the CCRA decision to the Federal Court.

At a hearing in June of this year, government lawyers argued that ambulances donated by Canadians through the CMDA were operating in West Bank, Gaza and East Jerusalem settlements. The government also alleged that the ambulances were used for non-medical purposes as well. These "activities... which lend support to Israeli settlements beyond its pre-1967 borders," the CCRA argued, undermine Canadian public policy regarding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

The CMDA is the Canadian branch of Magen David Adom (MDA), which was established in 1931 to collect and dispense blood and equipment to medical institutions and to operate ambulances. Although it is not recognized as such by the International Red Cross Societies, the MDA touts itself as Israel's equivalent of the Red Cross. The organization openly proclaims itself as a humanitarian group, yet unabashedly and wholeheartedly supports the Israel Defense Forces. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.