Magazine article The Spectator

Cast a Long Shadow

Magazine article The Spectator

Cast a Long Shadow

Article excerpt


by David Thomson

Basic Books, £13.99, pp. 183,

ISBN 9780465003396

Many years ago I invited a young student of mine to see Psycho, a film of which she had never heard, made by a director (Hitchcock) with whose name she was unfamiliar and shot in a format (black-and-white) whose apparent old-fashionedness so mystifed her she wondered aloud why no one thought to complain to the projectionist.

Yet, shrieking on cue at all the spooky moments, she ultimately admitted to having been so bowled over by the film that she asked what other Hitchcocks she ought to see. I recommended North by Northwest - only subsequently to learn, to my stupefaction, that she had found it boring. Boring? The most euphoriainducing comedy thriller in cinema history? I asked her why. 'Well, ' she replied. 'I was under the impression he made horror movies.'

If I begin my review by quoting that trivial anecdote, it's because it constitutes a neat encapsulation of what the critic David Thomson calls 'the moment of Psycho'.

Confounding the traditional qualms of the studio bosses - which is why, accustomed to bountiful budgets and generous shooting schedules, Hitchcock had to work so cheaply and swiftly - it gave him not just his biggest hit but genuinely altered the course of the American cinema. Despite himself, he became the patron saint, so to speak, of slasher movies. Only one other film in his lengthy and prolific career (The Birds, Psycho's immediate successor in the canon) offered anything like the same intoxicating cocktail of graphic gore and knowing drollery. Yet it was from these two exceptions to the Hitchcockian rule that his influence on several generations of filmmakers - Thomson cites, among others, Polanski, Kubrick, Chabrol, Scorsese, De Palma, as well as those undistinguished, indistinguishable hacks he gathers under the dismissive rubric 'The Texas Chain-Saw Massacre, et cetera' - tended to derive.

Unsurprisingly, none of his epigones has ever proved able to mix the cocktail to perfection, since their more or less laborious efforts have all lacked, in Thomson's inspired locution, 'the black cream of Hitchcock's humour'. Yet they keep tryqing, even now, and Norman Bates' sinisterly puppyish 'My mother's not herself today', a joke that no one who hasn't seen the film will get and no one who has will fail to get, has long since degenerated into the sort of half-jokey, half-creepy catch-phrase ('Make my day, punk') by which cultishness can be built into a Hollywood film even before it opens. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.