Magazine article The American Conservative

Mr. Natural Rights

Magazine article The American Conservative

Mr. Natural Rights

Article excerpt

Mr. Natural Rights [Liberty, State, and Union: The Political Theory of Thomas Jefferson, Luigi Marco Bassani, Mercer University Press, 277 pages]

THE LITERATURE ON JEFFERSON is truly enormous. One need only consult the Comprehensive Annotated Bibliography prepared by Frank Shuffelton, comprising several thousand citations, to get a sense of how extensive it is. Indeed, the Library of Congress notes that its Jefferson collection is so large that it is divided into no less than 100 categories. Certainly the most interesting, because the most enduringly relevant, of these is devoted to Jefferson's political thought - his theory of rights and his conclusions regarding the nature of government. Among the most recent studies of this side of Jefferson is that by Luigi Marco Bassani, professor of political theory at the University of Milan.

Liberty, State, and Union is a truly impressive volume. Bassani seeks to lay bare the fundamental presuppositions of Jefferson's poütics and to uncover the philosophy underlying America's most important founding document, the Declaration of Independence. In taking up this task, Bassani confronts some 70 years of scholarship that has attempted to sever the connection between Jefferson and Lockean natural rights.

Given Jefferson's singular importance among the nation's Founders, it is not surprising that over the years scholars have sought to appropriate him as an early proponent of the views they themselves embraced. Thus, since the Progressive Era, Jefferson has been portrayed as a species of civic humanist, a man who was suspicious of the instrumentalities of an emerging commercial society and who believed that the nation's virtue rested on an agrarian population active in political Ufe. A typical instance of this interpretation is that of Charles M. Wiltze, whose Jeffersonian Tradition in American Democracy, first published in 1935, offers a picture of Jefferson as an early social democrat who, had he lived, would have embraced many of the reforms of Roosevelt's New Deal.

Even earlier, Vernon Parrington's Main Currents in American Thought, published in 1927, painted Jefferson as a proto-socialist who distrusted industry and everything that foUowed in its wake, a staunch opponent of the capitaUst society that was emerging in the AngloBritish world in the 18th century. This Progressivist interprétation clashed head on with the then prevailing view of Jefferson as a classical liberal. Parrington's essay had the effect of dividing Jefferson scholarship into competing camps that persist to this day. Some historians continue to view Jefferson as a Lockean Uberai who distrusted government and subscribed to the strictest limits on the actions of the civil magistrate; others regard him as an agrarian with sociaUst leanings who only adhered to the principles of private property so far as they served certain poUtical ends.

Perhaps the most egregious examples of invoking Jefferson for purely transient poUtical purposes are the inscriptions on the Jefferson Memorial in Washington, D.C. Planned and built during the administration of Franklin D. Roosevelt, the waUs of the memorial are adorned with quotations from Jefferson's writings, many of which suggest that Jefferson advocated positions consistent with the aims of the New Deal - with which he would, in fact, have had Utile sympathy. Thus, Jefferson's admonition that an educated electorate was essential if Uberty were to be preserved is transmuted into a call for universal public education. And his caution that man, as he advances in his understanding of the world, must accompany his greater enlightenment with changes in his social institutions becomes a justification for a new theory of government in keeping with the social-democratic principles that animated the New Deal.

Bassani's conclusions are in direct contrast to those of the majority of today's historians, who have argued that Jefferson distrusted commerce and would have supported legislation to provide for a more equitable distribution of property. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.