Magazine article Workforce Management

Dissident Group Sounds off on Perceived Show Snub

Magazine article Workforce Management

Dissident Group Sounds off on Perceived Show Snub

Article excerpt

Every year since anyone can remember, past presidents and board chairs of the Society for Human Resource Management have eagerly awaited their invitations to attend the organization's annual conference as guests of honor.

The letters usually arrive in early March, but this year they never came. Instead, past honorees who contacted SHRM learned through emails that the provision offering free registration had been repealed, which prompted accusations of retaliation against former association executives who have been critical of recent board decisions.

The former executives, who last year formed the SHRM Members for Transparency group, have compiled a detailed list of grievances against association leaders. That list includes the SHRM board's 2005 decision to pay board members an annual honorarium of $10,000 to $20,000, depending on the position, and its vote last year to nearly double that amount and allow reimbursement for business-class travel for board members. The group is calling for an independent review of the board's compensation plan.

In 2010, the board also raised SHRM's annual membership fees from $160 to $180 per year and voted to tie future increases to the consumer price index--a move that angered many transparency group members.

Other concerns include the number of board members without credentials from the HR Certification Institute, or HRCI, which is affiliated with SHRM. Currently, only four of 11 members have this certification, which is viewed as the industry standard for evaluating human resources practitioners' expertise.

As the largest HR professional association prepares for its 63rd annual conference, scheduled for June 26 to 29 in Las Vegas, frustration among the transparency group members is growing. The group's website lists 46 official members--all former board chairs and board members of SHRM, the SHRM Foundation and the HRCI.

It's a fraction of SHRM's 250,000-plus membership, but an impressive group that includes former SHRM CEO Mike Losey, who is acting as the transparency group's president, and longtime SHRM member Jac Fitz-enz, CEO of Human Capital Source, in San Jose, California. Last month, Fitz-enz announced that he was quitting SHRM in protest.

SHRM board leaders "have acted arbitrarily in the last couple of years and made decisions that run counter to the behavior of a nonprofit board," Fitz-enz says. "The board is not sharing information as it should. What they do they are doing behind closed doors."

SHRM has seen tremendous growth in the past decade, both in membership and revenue, but it has also seen upheaval in its leadership and has come under increasing criticism from those who feel that SHRM has lost touch with its members' needs.

Losey held the CEO title from 1990 to 2000. Since then four leaders have headed the organization, including interim president and CEO Henry Jackson. The organization is currently looking for a permanent leader.

The latest controversy over rescinding complimentary conference registration (the conference fee costs as much as $1,525 for members) to former SHRM leaders is a slap in the face, says Kathleen McComber, a former SHRM board chair who has also served on the SHRM Foundation and HRCI boards.

"Since I left the board in 1999, I've gotten a special letter every year telling me that I was invited as a distinguished guest. In March I hadn't gotten it so I contacted SHRM to ask when I should expect it. I got an email saying it would be forthcoming. It never came."

In an email to Workforce Management, Jackson provided this explanation for the board's decision to end the tradition: "SHRM has come to believe that the complimentary registration practice is most beneficial to SHRM and its members when it helps to advance the current strategic agenda and activities. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.