Magazine article Behavioral Healthcare Executive

Psych Hospital Closure Illegal without Community Reinvestment

Magazine article Behavioral Healthcare Executive

Psych Hospital Closure Illegal without Community Reinvestment

Article excerpt

To close a gaping budget hole, Gov. Pat Quinn of Illinois plans to close psychiatric institutions and slash Medicaid, resulting in the elimination of acute-care options for thousands of patients. While behavioral health advocates favor fewer psychiatric hospitalizations, they demand that all savings from the closures be reinvested into the community, as is required by law. Otherwise, they argue, the only alternative for many patients in crisis will be hospital emergency rooms and jails.

In Illinois, a 2006 statute, the Community Services Act, requires reinvestment into the community of money saved when psychiatric facilities are closed. But mental health advocates say the state is now flouting this law by its planned closures, and are suing to stop this from taking place.

Gov. Quinn wants to close two institutions, put patients into community-based systems, and cut those as well. And, to make the situation a perfect storm, the proposal would also cut $2.7 billion from Medicaid.

In all, the mental health cuts proposed by Gov.QuinnonFeb.22fromFY2012toFY 2013 total $58.4 million or 40 percent. The Governor challenged the legislature to fix the budget problem, which was precipitated by the state's pension liability, in time to sign the new budget in May.

The Governor's proposal originated in January with announcement of his plan to "rebalance" the state's approach to people with mental health conditions and developmental disabilities by transitioning people from institutions to community care. "My administration is committed to increasing community care options," he said. "The approach we are taking will allow for the safe transition of care for some of our most vulnerable citizens to community care settings."

The sticking point is that only some of the savings from closing the two hospitals would go back into the community. This violates the Community Services Act, and on top of the cuts, threatens to decimate mental health treatment in the state, advocates say.

The lawsuit

The first hospital to be closed would be the 75bed Tinley Park Mental Health Center, due to be shut down on June 30. The center's budget is $20.1 million; the state would reinvest only $12.9 million, saving $8.1 million. The advocates want that money to be reinvested in the community. "Our view is that the law requires them to spend all of the money," said Mark Heyrman, a University of Chicago law school professor who sued the state in February on behalf of advocates. "The law says they have to spend the whole 20 million, and then they have to come up with a written plan and consult with advocacy groups."

The plaintiffs in Heyrman's lawsuit are Mental Health America of Illinois, the National Alliance of Mental Illness of Illinois, and Lisa Gardiola, a patient formerly hospitalized at Tinely Park who would require readmission in the event of a relapse. The lawsuit was filed in the Circuit Court of Cook County in Illinois.

Heyrman, who is on the public policy committee of Mental Health America, says that if Tinley Park or other programs are closed, the people served there need to be treated elsewhere.

The plaintiffs are seeking to require the state to maintain and operate Tinley Park and restore the bed capacity until the state develops a plan, and shares the plan with advocates, to redirect any saved money into the community.

"Our lawsuit is designed to prevent the state from closing state psychiatric i nstitutions and not substituting appropriate services in the community," said Heyrman. He explains that theCommunity Services Act unintentionally had the effect of preventing closures. After its passage, the state stopped closing psychiatric hospitals because there was no longer any incentive to close them just to save money - at least until it got into fiscal trouble.

"The state's past and present desire to close hospitals is not based on any clinical views about the value of community integration - it was and is driven by the desire to save money," he said. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.