Magazine article Times Educational Supplement

Schools - 'Not the Leaps and Bounds That Were Promised': News

Magazine article Times Educational Supplement

Schools - 'Not the Leaps and Bounds That Were Promised': News

Article excerpt

'Modest' charter school progress fails to satisfy critics in the US.

After more than 20 years of existence in the US, and having failed to deliver on expectations of performance, charter schools have finally started to show marginal improvements across the board, a major new study reveals.

However, the research also shows that almost a third of charters - independent, state-funded schools - still deliver a "significantly weaker" performance in mathematics than their traditional state-maintained counterparts, while a fifth lag behind in reading.

Even the overall boost in performance is attributed to widespread closures of failing charters and an increase in the number of high-performing ones, rather than a wholesale improvement of existing schools.

The findings were published last week in the latest National Charter School Study, a widely cited report produced every four years by the Center for Research on Education Outcomes (Credo), part of Stanford University in California.

The approach to charter schools and their performance varies considerably from state to state. However, the findings will prove of interest to politicians not only in the US but also around the world, as more schools are placed in the hands of organisations outside direct government control. England, Sweden and New Zealand have all made moves to transfer management of schools to external providers.

In 2009, Credo issued the first comprehensive research into the performance of charter schools. The study, which considered 16 states, showed that just 17 per cent of charter schools outperformed mainstream schools, whereas 37 per cent performed "significantly worse".

The latest study analysed the test scores of charter schools in 26 states as well as in New York City. It shows that, on average, the schools have made improvements, but it says that this is mainly down to the closure of poorly performing charters and a drop in the standards of local state- maintained schools.

"The 2013 Credo study finds that charters in the original 16 states have made modest progress in raising student performance in both reading and mathematics, caused in part by the closure of 8 per cent of the charters in those states in the intervening years since the 2009 report as well as declining performance in the comparison traditional public schools over the same period," the document states. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.