Magazine article Times Educational Supplement

Workforce - 'Superstars' Won't Save the Day, Expert Claims: News

Magazine article Times Educational Supplement

Workforce - 'Superstars' Won't Save the Day, Expert Claims: News

Article excerpt

Finnish official says recruiting 'smarter' staff is not key to success.

Improving the calibre of the teachers joining the profession is not a "silver bullet" for raising educational standards and student attainment, a renowned global education expert has claimed.

Pasi Sahlberg, a leading campaigner and government official in Finland - a country that is consistently ranked among the top performers in international league tables - this week insisted that luring high-flying young people into teaching would not lead to success.

The warning comes at a time when many countries, desperate to improve their league-table positions, have explicitly focused on attracting the most talented graduates into the classroom.

England's education secretary Michael Gove has spoken of the importance of enticing "the brightest and the best" university-leavers into the profession, while his US counterpart, Arne Duncan, has also stressed the need to "transform the teaching profession and ensure that the next generation of teachers is the very best we can offer our children".

But Mr Sahlberg said that the emphasis on better teachers was misplaced. "We need good teachers, but I'm not sure we need superstar teachers," he told TES at the World Innovation Summit for Education (Wise) in Qatar. "I'm not convinced you can enhance your teacher community to the point that it will make a real difference (to education) standards. Just trying to get smarter people into teaching doesn't make a difference."

His comments come as debate rages in England over whether all teachers should have formal qualifications.

In the most recent Programme for International Student Assessment (Pisa) league tables, Finland was ranked third in the world for reading, sixth for maths and second for science. In a survey of adult skills published last month by the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (which also runs Pisa), it fared even better, coming second only to Japan in both literacy and numeracy.

The idea that teacher quality is the key to improving schools has become increasingly widespread in recent years. Sir Michael Barber, who was education adviser to former British prime minister Tony Blair when he was in office, wrote in a highly influential report for the McKinsey consultancy: "The quality of an education system cannot exceed the quality of its teachers."

But although many observers have attributed Finland's enviable reputation to the strength of its teaching workforce, Mr Sahlberg told the summit in Doha that the idea of teacher quality as a "silver bullet" was wrong. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.