Magazine article Times Educational Supplement

Window Pains

Magazine article Times Educational Supplement

Window Pains

Article excerpt

It was that time again: we dutifully handed over our much-marked exercise books for inspection.

"You spend more time looking at our books than our lessons," one teacher commented to the powers that be.

"But that's where the evidence is these days," we were told. "Your books are your shop window; they show what the pupils can really do."

I was surprised. Mostly because I wasn't aware that I was running a shop, but also by the notion that everything they wanted to know could be gleaned from looking in the children's books. Our school loves scrutinising books because Ofsted loves scrutinising books. The inspectorate has moved into window-shopping in a big way.

But the books don't tell you the whole story. You wouldn't know that the three bald sentences scribed in Callum's last literacy lesson took 40 minutes of gruelling effort from both him and me. You would have no idea that Rebecca's beautifully written story was faithfully copied from her reading book when the supply teacher wasn't looking. You might open Ryan's dog-eared science book and see the atrocious handwriting and a multitude of corrected spellings, none of which indicate that he was the only child to correctly explain evaporation using the word "molecules".

The problem with assessing everything on written evidence is that you miss the crucial aspects of teaching: the moment when something suddenly clicks for a child; the discussions when, just for a few minutes, everyone in the class is totally engaged and focused on the same idea; the lesson when a shy pupil speaks up for the first time and gives an answer you didn't think was possible for him or her. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.