Magazine article Times Educational Supplement

Why Bill to Limit Strike Action 'May Have Opposite Effect'

Magazine article Times Educational Supplement

Why Bill to Limit Strike Action 'May Have Opposite Effect'

Article excerpt

New ballot rules could fuel rise in local school walkouts, unions say

Government proposals to tighten rules on strike ballots could have the opposite effect and inspire a flurry of local industrial action in schools, education unions have claimed.

Teachers were among the tens of thousands of people demonstrating against the controversial Trade Union Bill outside the Conservative Party conference in Manchester on Sunday.

But plans to limit strikes and other industrial action, by imposing higher voting thresholds for ballots, could backfire on the government, according to teachers' leaders. Peter Pendle, deputy general secretary of the ATL union, told TES that changes to rules on ballot turnouts could lead to a spike in localised action at schools and colleges.

Currently, industrial action can take place as long as the majority of those taking part in a ballot vote in favour. But if the proposals go through, at least 50 per cent of the members will need to turn out in a ballot and 40 per cent will need to say yes.

"The Trade Union Bill is likely to result in industrial action moving from national to local action because it will become harder to reach the threshold in national ballots, without the government agreeing to bring voting into the 21st century and allowing a change in voting methods, which it appears reluctant to do," Mr Pendle told TES. "This is likely to lead to an increase in local action, where it remains easier to reach the threshold."

In June 2011, the ATL and the NUT took part in a national strike over changes to pensions. In the NUT ballot, 92 per cent voted in favour of strike action, with a turnout of 40 per cent. The ATL result was 83 per cent in favour of a strike on a 35 per cent turnout. Neither union would have been able to strike had the bill been in place.

'Shooting themselves in the foot'

The general secretary of Voice, the no-strike alternative to the main classroom unions, also predicts a rise in localised action in response to the government's crackdown on trade unions.

"Workers will still take industrial action but it's going to be more localised. It wouldn't take too much organisation to get a few schools in the same area, who share the same national concerns, to take action on the same day," Voice general secretary Deborah Lawson told TES.

She warned that the bill - which includes allowing employers to use agency workers to replace striking staff and doubling the amount of notice unions have to give for a strike to 14 days - was likely to fuel a more hostile and aggressive response from union members. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.