Magazine article New Internationalist

Claiming Our Victories

Magazine article New Internationalist

Claiming Our Victories

Article excerpt

Every so often we see an explosion of protest that propels an urgent issue to the fore of public debate. The global justice movement did this with the 1999 revolt in Seattle against the World Trade Organization (WTO). The Occupy movement did it in 2011. And #BlackLivesMatter has done it in the US over the past year and a half.

But do these mobilizations really create change?

The default stance in our society is to take refuge in cynicism: 'Those protests didn't do anything,' the sceptics argue. Conveniently enough, it takes no evidence to assert this claim. And since most people do not bother to track progress on specific social issues, they are likely to nod their heads in gloomy assent.

Fortunately for those not wedded to pessimism, this position is often wrong.

Take the global justice movement. Almost a decade after the Seattle protests, a local newspaper writer quipped, 'Remind me again what those demonstrations against the WTO actually accomplished.'

He meant this as a damning indictment. In fact, it mostly revealed his ignorance.

Those who cared to pay attention saw that the Seattle protests set offa revolt among representatives from the Global South within the WTO. The organization struggled for at least a decade to regain its former swagger. Arguably, it never has.

After further protests in Quebec City, Miami and Mar del Plata, Argentina, the pro-corporate dream of a creating a Free Trade Area of the Americas extending from the Canadian north to the Southern Cone collapsed entirely.

Around the same time, in 2005, advocates brokered a landmark debt cancellation agreement. This allowed countries in Africa and beyond to spend billions of dollars on their people's needs, rather than sending the money to wealthy creditors. It also vindicated a major demand of Seattle protesters.

In the case of Occupy, the New York Times' Andrew Ross Sorkin insisted on the movement's first anniversary that it had been 'a fad' of little consequence. In truth, the outbreak of defiance that began on Wall Street and spread to some 1,500 encampments worldwide sent shockwaves that reverberate still.

In the months before Occupy, the US political class had been mired in debates about slashing government budgets. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.