Magazine article The Spectator

Exhibitions: The Radical Eye - Modernist Photography from the Sir Elton John Collection

Magazine article The Spectator

Exhibitions: The Radical Eye - Modernist Photography from the Sir Elton John Collection

Article excerpt

'Radical' is like 'creative', a word that has been enfeebled to the point of meaninglessness. Everybody seems to want to be both, but nobody has any clear idea of what might be involved. In the case of this exhibition, radical could refer either to aesthetic or political themes; neither seems quite right.

Never mind, 'modernist' has, with the passage of time, become more firmly anchored. We now know it was a movement in the arts that began in about the 1880s and ended in, very roughly, the 1950s or '60s. It was a period in which art became preoccupied with form as a determinant -- rather than the servant -- of content.

In the context of photography, the modernist impulse was best summed up by the New York street snapper Garry Winogrand: 'Photography,' he said, 'is not about the thing photographed. It is about how that thing looks photographed.' The form -- lens, film, post-processing -- produced not a simulacrum of reality, but, rather, an entirely new version.

To talk of modernist photography, therefore, makes sense. When the technology was first created in the 1830s it was immediately identified as a way of faithfully reproducing reality. As this seemed to usurp the art of painting, it tended to drive painters towards less literal methods -- hence impressionism, expressionism, surrealism, modernism etc. Even today, David Hockney wages a painted war on the camera's one-eyed perspective.

So when photography embraced modernism in what the curators of this show call 'the classic modernist period of the 1920-50s', it did so with a form of painting envy. Artists with brushes were proving themselves closer to the cutting edge of the contemporary and what had been a new technology was in danger of being outdated.

The most obviously modernist works in this show, notably by Man Ray, do, indeed, go far beyond mere representation. Ray regularly used a processing method known as solarisation. This involved reversals of tone -- black to white, white to black. The effect, in Ray's hands at least, dramatically removes the image to another realm, dreamed or hallucinated. His 1936 portrait of Dora Maar makes her face look almost surgically removed and being caressed by a ghostly version of her own hand.

This was surrealism, the modernist form that came most naturally to many of these photographers. Aesthetically, its effects could be catastrophic. Herbert Bayer's 'Self-Portrait' (1932) is student stuff. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.