Magazine article Variety

Thesps' Work Travels Well

Magazine article Variety

Thesps' Work Travels Well

Article excerpt

Back in May at the Cannes Film Festival, a colleague was gushing - as was pretty much everyone, this critic included - about Isabelle Huppert's icecool, high-wire tour de force as a rape victim with a very unusual psychology in Paul Verhoeven's comeback feature "Elle."

"She should win the Oscar in a walk," she asserted, before adding a predictable caveat. "Shame awards voters won't touch that performance with a 50-foot-pole."

Seven months later, my colleague might not be feeling so pessimistic. Despite being housed in a chilly, controversial, French-language film, Huppert has emerged as the surprise dark horse of the season so far, bulldozing through the major critics' awards and landing a Golden Globe nomination.

Whether she scores her first-ever Oscar nomination in a competitive category remains to be seen, but she's very much in the conversation. That's unprecedented territory for Huppert, despite the Frenchwoman's reputation as one of the greatest in her field, with a long, celebrated filmography of adventurous work that was never on the Academy's radar - from "The Piano Teacher" to "The Lacemaker" to "8 Women."

For critics, she epitomizes the kind of international performer who would rack up multiple Oscar nods "in a perfect world"; come January, that perfect world might be the real one.

To be fair, there's plenty of precedent for performers in left-field foreign or arthouse films bucking the odds to break into the Oscar race: The past two years alone have seen Marion Cotillard ("Two Days, One Night") and Charlotte Rampling ("45 Years") elbow aside glossier, more aggressively campaigned contenders on the strength of their work. But for every acclaimed outsider who makes the cut, there are equally deserving names who never come close, insurmountably hindered by the low profile and/or challenging nature of their films.

For example, if Huppert can join the likes of Emma Stone and Natalie Portman in this year's lead actress discussion, why shouldn't Sônia Braga? Long after her foray into Hollywood, the Brazilian veteran landed the role of a lifetime in Kleber Mendonca Filho's Cannes critics' favorite "Aquarius": As a defiant bohemian widow defending her beloved apartment from venal property developers, she's sexy, steel-nerved, and quietly heartbreaking as she reconciles her cherished past to an increasingly alienating present.

Yet aside from a win with the San Diego film critics, she's found no traction this season - Vitagraph Films, the pic's U.S. distributor, simply hasn't the clout to push her into the race. Huppert, by contrast, has expert underdog campaigners Sony Pictures Classics - the same outfit behind Michael Haneke's "Amour," which landed five noms in 2013 - working for her.

While "Aquarius" has also had to sit out the Oscar race for foreign-language film - after the Brazilian selectors refused, on political grounds, to submit the film - its fellow Cannes sensation "Toni Erdmann" has been luckier. German director Maren Ade's poignant, sometimes raucous father-daughter dramedy is viewed as the one to beat in that category, and has duly taken a number of precursor awards.

Yet while the film is driven significantly by two mercurial lead performances, stars Sandra Hüller and Peter Simonischek haven't attracted a whisper of Oscar talk. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.