Magazine article Black Issues in Higher Education

Faculty Club: The American University; Private Benefit or Public Good?

Magazine article Black Issues in Higher Education

Faculty Club: The American University; Private Benefit or Public Good?

Article excerpt


Harvard University's Dr. Cornel West, the scheduled keynoter, wasn't able to make it, but the nearly 1,000 faculty and administrators who gathered for the American Association of Higher Education's 10th annual Forum on Faculty Roles and Rewards received a rousing call to arms nonetheless.

These are perilous times for higher education, according to the pinch-hitting keynoter, Dr. Edward Zlotkowski, a professor of English at Bentley College, founder of the Bentley Service-Learning Center, senior associate for service-learning with the American Association for Higher Education, and senior fellow with Campus Compact.

Zlotkowski got a rousing response when he spelled out the danger: "I am worried right now that the university is viewed as a private benefit, not a public good. And unless we can recast it as a publicly engaged venture, I think our very future is at stake."

The professor's catalog of the ills of the modern university was encyclopedic.

An embrace of a market-driven sense of competition has turned the academy into a "global jungle whose primordial law is survival of the fittest," Zlotkowski says.

As a result, underprepared students have been driven out of elite institutions -- and well-nigh out of higher education itself. Meanwhile, "diversity" has become a cloak for tokenism of the worst kind and, perhaps most frighteningly, the march of new pedagogies and new research methods -- based on science, not the "habits, hearsay and traditions" of the past -- has been stopped in its tracks "because elite institutions simply do not need them (to win) within the competitive market for students," Zlotkowski says.

Matters are nearing the point of crisis, as the varied responses to the events of Sept. 11 revealed. While many of the nation's faculty responded "heroically" to the crisis, as AAHE President Dr. Yolanda Moses says, still others barely mentioned the tragedy in class because, Zlotkowski says, "they simply did not know how to respond professionally to the tragedy. They knew how to respond personally and they did wonderfully respond."

But, in Zlotkowski's eyes, the events of Sept. 11 served to highlight the marked failure of campuses across the nation to embrace what the faculty at the University of Utah called in a 1995 document "socially responsive knowledge."

Zlotkowski explained by noting that the academy's major commitments over the past century have been to the development and dissemination of two kinds of knowledge: foundational knowledge and professional knowledge. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.