Magazine article The Spectator

What the Tories Must Fear Most Is That the Voters Are No Longer Frightened of Demon Eyes

Magazine article The Spectator

What the Tories Must Fear Most Is That the Voters Are No Longer Frightened of Demon Eyes

Article excerpt

A secret fear haunts the Tories. What if that Demon Eyes billboard campaign before the last election campaign actually worked? Let me explain. No doubt you remember the billboard. Tony Blair's face appeared, but with the eyes stripped out and replaced with the eyes of some kind of a devil. The implication was clear. Beneath Mr Blair's smiling reassurances about sticking to Tory spending plans, not renationalising, not raising taxes, and all the rest, lay concealed a man - and a party - whose enthusiasm for full-blooded socialism was undimmed.

We were, the advertising pitch insinuated, being taken in. After winning the election, Blair would rip off his neo-Thatcherite mask and reveal himself for the Marxist he had always been. Taxes would rise, spending would go through the roof, and Britain would end up as Britain always had after voting Labour: in hock.

You may also remember the press reaction to the campaign. It was almost universally denounced as in poor taste, and sure to prove counterproductive. Christians objected to the use of the Satanic imagery for party political purposes. Liberals objected to the crudity of the fearmongering. The quieter kind of Conservatives objected both to this rather American style of negative campaigning, and also to the recourse to such a personal method of attack.

John Major was among that quieter kind of Conservative. He was not happy about the message or the billboard. The demonic campaign theme was dropped, and was never actually used during the election campaign proper. The billboards had in fact been shown only briefly, and not during the general election at all, but many months before it. The almost universal conclusion had been that it had been an error of taste and judgment.

When, during the general election itself, an election broadcast codenamed 'Faust' was shown to Major, it is said that he so disliked it that he refused to finish watching it, and ordered it to be scrapped at once. The broadcast had featured a Blair-like figure making a Faustian pact with the Devil, agreeing to pretend to be a moderate if the Devil would deliver him a general election victory. The broadcast was never shown.

But the image ran deep, and stuck. It is probably the only image from that campaign which did. Nobody who took the remotest interest in politics at the time will ever forget the idea behind the poster. However, critics of the theme who do acknowledge that it was, at least, unforgettable argued that it was also unhelpful, and lowered the Tories in public estimation.

I thought it was a brilliant idea. I was as gripped as anybody by the imagery, of course, but to gain attention by shock is no proof of a successful pitch, unless the shock redounds to the advertiser's advantage. I thought it did and for a simple reason. It went with the grain of the electorate's fears, and especially wavering Tory voters' fears, about Tony Blair and his New Labour project.

For was this not precisely what worried Britain in 1997? The nation had hardened its heart against the Conservative government, and there was no realistic prospect of altering that, but anxiety persisted about the bona fides of the rival party bidding for our support. We knew Mr Blair had, earlier in his career, appeared to support the very version of Labour which he now promised us he had gone into politics to abolish. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.