Magazine article Public Finance

Are Government Cost Cuts Really Up to Speed?

Magazine article Public Finance

Are Government Cost Cuts Really Up to Speed?

Article excerpt

When Chancellor Gordon Brown delivered his Budget statement on March 16, he trumpeted the success of his cost-cutting drive.

He declared with relish that progress towards meeting the £21.5bn annual efficiency savings target laid down by Sir Peter Gershon was ahead of schedule.

Brown told MPs that 7.800 civil service posts had been earmarked for relocation outside the Southeast and £14bn out of £30bn-worth of government assets to be sold had been identified.

'I can report, ahead of target, the first £2bn of value-for-money Gershon savings, on top of £2bn savings in procurement announced in December,' he added. 'And I can also report, on target, the reduction of the first 12,500 civil service posts.'

But in crowing about these apparent successes Brown has provoked fresh doubts about the credibility of the Gershon agenda.

It is a long-running argument centred on the governments refusal to allow an independent body, such as the National Audit Office, to scrutinise savings that departments claim to achieve.

The NAO has given unpublished advice to ministries on their efficiency technical notes (ETNs), which set out the methodologies for quantifying savings. But, crucially, the figures produced will not subsequently be audited.

As a result, questions have been raised about how the savings are calculated and whether claims of success can be accepted.

Business lobby group the CBI firmly backs the Gershon objectives but has expressed fears that the savings will be paper rather than real ones and owe more to political expediency than greater efficiency.

Margaret Murray, the CBIs head of public services policy, told Public Finance why.

'The key thing is transparency and we'd like the government to commit to independent scrutiny of all claimed efficiency gains, for instance by the NAO or the Audit Commission, and to making available all measurement information,' she said.

'Efficiency matters to all taxpayers and public service users, not just business. The plans to deliver the Gershon objectives require far more rigour than we have seen to date.'

Following Browns statement the CBI set about trying to verify his claims. A briefing paper seen by PF outlines a breakdown of the £2bn apparently achieved, compiled by CBI policy officers by scrutinising the Budget Red Book, requesting information from Whitehall departments and trawling through ETNs. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.