Magazine article The Spectator

It Is Hard to Exaggerate the Scale of the Immigration Crisis That Now Faces Tony Blair

Magazine article The Spectator

It Is Hard to Exaggerate the Scale of the Immigration Crisis That Now Faces Tony Blair

Article excerpt

After the 2001 general election massacre, a consensus swiftly established itself in the Conservative party. William Hague had fought on the wrong issues. Instead of Europe and asylum, his chosen battlegrounds, he should have championed health and education. Hague's mistake, so conventional wisdom held, doomed the Conservatives to be the rancid voice of the malcontents, the losers, the racists: the detritus of 21st-century Britain.

This persuasive analysis, associated above all with the so-called 'modernisers', swiftly took hold in Tory high command after Hague's abrupt departure. It held sway under Iain Duncan Smith, and even more so under Michael Howard. For the last three years prodigious efforts have gone into establishing the Conservative party as sound on public services. This project reached its culmination back in February, when the shadow Chancellor Oliver Letwin promised to meet Gordon Brown's hugely ambitious spending targets for health and education.

This was the moment, so the modernisers felt, when the Conservative party returned to the British political mainstream. Europe seemed to have gone off the radar screen, asylum-seekers reduced to a bureaucratic argument, the Hague heresy expunged. The Conservatives seemed set to fight the general election, most likely to be held on 5 May next year, on public-service reform.

But elections can never be worked out as abstractions. They are always forged in the white heat of events, and events have moved precipitately in the last two to three weeks. First came the al-Qa'eda bombs in Madrid. These brought about instant regime change in Spain, with the consequent loss of Tony Blair's closest European ally. As a direct result, the European constitution blocked by the Blair/Aznar alliance - is back at the top of the agenda.

This is a very difficult issue for the government. When plans for the constitution collapsed last year, there was an audible sigh of relief from Downing Street. Now the Prime Minister may be forced to sign a new treaty as early as this June, with ratification by member states over the next two years or so. This timetable is a nightmare, because it means that the row over the constitution will infect next year's general election, with devastating consequences for Tony Blair's relationship with News International. Last Sunday the News of the World called Tony Blair a 'traitor' for giving in so readily over the constitution last weekend in Brussels. This very harsh language raises the issue of how the NoW, or for that matter the Sun, could possibly endorse a leader they regard as treasonable at a general election.

More lethal still are immigration and asylum. Like the European constitution, immigration seemed to have died as an electoral issue. The tide of asylum-seekers was slowing, while the Tories were chary of raising the matter for fear of being labelled racist. This can no longer be the case, thanks to the deeply disturbing revelations about immigration policy over the last three weeks.

It is hard to exaggerate the scale of the crisis that now faces Tony Blair and his Home secretary. They are confronted with a failure of public policy of massive dimensions. Superb Sunday Times journalism and despairing whistle-blowers have between them brought to light a giant scandal nothing less than the collapse of the immigration service. Revelations over the last few weeks have proved that the Home Office has been not merely the victim but, to all intents and purposes, the lackey of organised crime.

Reading the leaked letters from Foreign Office staff in the Bucharest embassy to immigration officials at Lunar House in Croydon just makes you want to weep. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.