Magazine article Public Finance

U-Turn on Pensions Comes at a Price

Magazine article Public Finance

U-Turn on Pensions Comes at a Price

Article excerpt

Government departments could still be forced to reduce entitlements for new public sector staff to meet its £13bn savings target across the sector - despite this week's surprise deal on the pension age.

While trade unions were celebrating a volte-face by Trade and Industry secretary Alan Johnson over plans to increase the pension age for all public sector staff- and ministers faced down criticism from business leaders - senior Whitehall sources told Public Finance that new entrants were most likely to pay the price.

Despite agreeing to retain a pension age of 60 for all existing civil service, education and NHS staff, the government has insisted that the £13bn in savings that would have been made over the next 50 years if the pension age had risen to 65 as planned, must still be found.

A senior government pensions expert told PF that a likely consequence is some reasonably significant reductions to retirement entitlements for new staff, who will be forced to join new schemes'.

One possibility is the introduction of a civil service, or local government, pension scheme based on a new employee's average salary, rather than the final salary calculation that existing staff would continue to enjoy. Less controversial possibilities include lower pension accrual rates for new staff and different packages relating to partners' pensions.

Johnson backed down from his commitment to increase the pension age for existing public servants at a meeting of the government/union Public Service Forum on October 18.

As late as October 16, Johnson claimed that the case for raising the pension age to 65 was 'irrefutable' because of escalating costs and demographic changes. In the face of fierce union opposition, the sector was set for a national strike by up to 3 million employees.

However, Johnson, Trades Union Congress general secretary Brendan Barber and union leaders across the civil service, health and education sectors reached a deal that retains a pension age of 60 for existing staff.

In return for Johnson's concession, the union general secretaries involved - including the FDA's Jonathan Baume, Unison's Dave Prentis and Mark Serwotka of the Public and Commercial Services union - accepted that new entrants to pension schemes would work to 65 before they could receive a full pension.

Johnson said: 'This is a sensible step forward, achieved through proper negotiations, which puts public sector pensions on a sound financial footing.'

In total, the PSF agreed a list of 12 'pension principles'. These have been sent to PF and reveal the full extent of the deal.

As well as protecting existing staff from an increased pension age, it guarantees that all other accrued pension rights of the existing workforce will be fully protected in the event of transition' to a separate scheme for new staff. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.