Magazine article The Spectator

'Mr Justice McCardie (1869-1933): Rebel, Reformer, Rogue, Judge', by Anthony Lentin - Review

Magazine article The Spectator

'Mr Justice McCardie (1869-1933): Rebel, Reformer, Rogue, Judge', by Anthony Lentin - Review

Article excerpt

Justice McCardie was anything but a conventional High Court judge. He left school at 15 and was called to the bar at 25. After ten years of provincial practice he turned down the offer from Joseph Chamberlain of a safe Conservative seat, although politics was then the conventional highway to the bench (unlike now when it is a cul de sac).

He also rejected an offer of silk, after withdrawing an earlier application which he thought the lord chancellor had been too slow to consider, and was, on the initiative of H.H. Asquith, the then liberal prime minister, appointed to the bench at 47 -- the youngest of his generation -- and the first junior to receive such promotion for over a century.

After his move to London chambers McCardie had become the counsel of choice of many city firms and was often preferred to established QCs. He managed,with the aid of 'devils', to conduct several cases at once. He once said, immodestly: 'My duty consists in walking from court to court to see that my leaders are attending to their business.' He had every weapon in the advocates' armoury and worked long hours for high fees. In his last years of practice he earned well over £1 million annually, in modern terms. Known in the Temple as 'Mac', he was not only admired but popular with his peers -- a double not always achieved in so competitive a profession.

His career on the bench became by contrast increasingly controversial. The philosopher and jurist Francis Bacon wrote that 'a much talking judge is like an ill-tuned cymbal'. In that respect, McCardie was the full brass band. Not only did he decide cases and direct juries as to what the law was, but he could rarely resist indicating what he thought it ought to be.

In a famous libel case arising out of General Dyer's suppression of the insurrection at Amritsar in 1919 -- when 400 Indians were shot dead -- he deliberately expressed his own view that the general had acted rightly. Not only did this challenge the convention that facts were for the jury, but his opinion also happened to be at odds with the government's accepted version of events -- that the general had presided over a massacre. Ramsay

MacDonald described McCardie's statement as 'unfortunate', leading the latter to threaten resignation, seek without success the support of the lord chancellor and publish a statement in self-defence in which he described the prime minister's comment as 'wholly untrue'.

In 1931, in the aftermath of the world economic crisis, the National Government imposed a 20 per cent cut on the salaries of all persons in His Majesty's Service. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.