Newspaper article The Journal (Newcastle, England)

Keith Hann Column

Newspaper article The Journal (Newcastle, England)

Keith Hann Column

Article excerpt

Byline: By Keith Hann

We have become so inured to the horrors of Iraq that reports of them no longer carry anything like the impact that they should.

Nevertheless, I was particularly struck by one line in the accounts of 21 teenage students being dragged off buses and killed earlier this month. It was the one describing how the gunmen methodically checked their identity cards so that they knew which ones to kill and which to spare.

Now, I don't think we actually need another argument against the introduction of identity cards here. But if we did, you have to admit that is a pretty good one. And don't tell me that Britain isn't Iraq.

Iraq wasn't in the state it is in before we helpfully invaded it alongside the Americans, in the interests of its better governance. Yes, it was a pretty foul dictatorship, and the sectarian killings were the work of the state rather than freelance enthusiasts. Yet overall it was, by current standards, relatively peaceful and stable.

But we have other and better arguments than that. We know that identity cards won't help to combat terrorism. Spain has had them for years, and a fat lot of good they did in preventing the Madrid train bombs.

We also know that they won't help to control illegal immigration, not least because you won't need one unless you are going to be in the country for more than three months.

But most convincingly of all, why would any nation in its right mind hand over up to pounds 19bn to set up a national biometric database to the Home Office? An organisation that has been politely described as "not fit for purpose," and which has a proven track record of being unable to organise refreshments in a brewery. That's before we even start to think about the litany of failed IT projects right across Government, most recently and spectacularly in the NHS.

Of course, the great national biometric database is presented as a boon to us all in helping to protect our own identities, but it doesn't explain what will happen to those who find that their documentation has been stolen or cloned by someone who turns up before them in the ID card queue. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.