Newspaper article Evening Chronicle (Newcastle, England)

Benitez's Record Has Earned Him the Absolute Right to Wheel and Deal

Newspaper article Evening Chronicle (Newcastle, England)

Benitez's Record Has Earned Him the Absolute Right to Wheel and Deal

Article excerpt

Byline: LEERYDER Analysing life in Black & White

IF Dennis Wise telling Kevin Keegan what type of players could do the business for Newcastle United was bad, then chief scout Graham Carr showing the way for Champions League winner and serial trophy collector Rafa Benitez surely now seems just as questionable.

Make no doubt about it, Carr has had great success stories with Newcastle with the likes of Yohan Cabaye, Mathieu Debuchy, Loic Remy, Cheick Tiote and Hatem Ben Arfa.

Even signings such as Mapou Yanga-Mbiwa and Remy Cabella could have been more successful if they had been managed differently.

The two players from Ligue 1, though, highlighted a power struggle in the boardroom during the Alan Pardew era and that eventually resulted in the Londoner jumping ship to Crystal Palace.

Carr has had disappointments too with the likes of Florian Thauvin, Henri Saivet and Seydou Doumbia proving major factors in the club's relegation.

There are flaws when asking a technical director to pick players for a manager.

It is believed Steve McClaren did not feel Aleksandar Mitrovic was good enough for United and asked for a new centre-forward 13 months ago.

Meanwhile, Pardew quickly axed players like Cabella soon after they arrived.

There flaws asking a director players manager Lee Like Pardew, McClaren found the club's transfer blueprint difficult despite going along with the idea after being appointed to a transfer committee which also included Lee Charnley, Carr and Bob Moncur.

The "transfer board" is not thought to be in operation any more.

However, the club's recruitment system does seem to be uncertain again these days.

Are we back to somebody else picking players for the boss? There has been talk Newcastle only want to bring in younger players and Carr will have a "direct role" in making that happen.

are when technical to pick for a manager Ryder However, you have to ask what use those type of players will be if (God forbid) Newcastle fail to get out of the Championship this season? That prospect is exactly what United have made a possibility by not investing in January. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.