Newspaper article THE JOURNAL RECORD

OK Supreme Court Referee Hears Jurisdiction Arguments for Smoking Lawsuit

Newspaper article THE JOURNAL RECORD

OK Supreme Court Referee Hears Jurisdiction Arguments for Smoking Lawsuit

Article excerpt

A lawsuit filed by a restaurant and a VFW post over state health department rules restricting smoking in some establishments should properly be heard in Oklahoma County District Court rather than Creek County, an Oklahoma Supreme Court referee was told Wednesday.

Gary Gardenhire, general counsel for the department, told Chief Referee Wayne Snow that the high court has previously assumed original jurisdiction over cases involving challenges of agency rules.

Under the rules, restaurants with a capacity of 50 or more could be designated as entirely smoking, entirely smoke-free or could allow smoking in separately ventilated rooms to shield other customers from the effects of secondhand smoke. Other types of businesses and workplaces would be affected by similar regulations.

In July, Creek County District Judge Donald Thompson issued a statewide temporary injunction against enforcement of the smoking regulations. Thompson refused to stay his ruling while appeals run their course.

The department contends that the proper venue for hearing a case of this magnitude is the county where the health department and Gov. Frank Keating reside. Gardenhire said that the case involves the governor's authority to approve such rules.

An action against a public officer must be brought in the county where the cause arose.

Under state law, Gardenhire said, the validity of a rule may be determined in a declaratory judgment action in the district court of the county of the residence of the person seeking relief or in the county where the rule is sought to be applied. However, he stressed, the latter is available as an optional venue only if it is alleged the rule interferes with or impairs or threatens to interfere with or impair, the legal rights or privileges of a plaintiff.

Gardenhire said that Thompson improperly issued a sweeping order affecting not just the two plaintiff establishments, or even all restaurants, but other types of businesses not a part of the lawsuit.

"It's clearly a matter of statewide application," he said. "We think it far exceeded the venue power and the subject matter jurisdiction issues before the court. We think this is an important case that needs to be decided."

Gardenhire said that Thompson's injunction should be dissolved and the case transferred to Oklahoma County or retained and consolidated with a pending appeal.

Snow asked the department attorney what difference it makes whether the case is heard in Creek County or Oklahoma County.

"What's so magical about Oklahoma County?" the referee asked.

Gardenhire said that Oklahoma County is the county of residence of the public officers involved, and of the agency. He also told Snow that Thompson's ruling should be limited to the two entities who brought the suit.

"The court exceeded its jurisdiction," he said.

Sen. Mike Morgan, D-Stillwater, attorney for the two restaurants, said that following Gardenhire's reasoning, everyone aggrieved by a particular regulation would have to file their own lawsuit rather than being able to rely upon decisions with statewide application. …

Author Advanced search


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.