Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Protest Slogan on Home Pits Zoning Laws against Free Speech

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Protest Slogan on Home Pits Zoning Laws against Free Speech

Article excerpt

A North Carolina man and the ACLU are suing Cary, N.C., after the town told him to remove a protest slogan he had painted on the side of his home. He says it's a free-speech issue, but the town argues he's breaking local zoning laws.

There's political speech, commercial speech, and of course good old free speech. In Cary, N.C., there's also "house speech."

Amid the idyll of a carefully planned Sun Belt town stands a monument to one man's discontent: a white split-level ranch, its facade spray painted in garish fluorescent orange with the words "Screwed by the town of Cary."

A thumb-poke in the eye of a tony town, the fluorescent-orange lament of resident David Bowden has been a point of both embarrassment and amusement since he paid someone $200 to paint it in August.

Cary officials responded by threatening to fine Mr. Bowden unless he paints over the letters - and puts his protest on a five-square- foot sign, per the zoning laws. But wait. Enter the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), which recently filed a lawsuit that questions the town's ability to supplant political speech with communal taste, thus turning Bowden's bid to fight city hall with a can of spray paint into a First Amendment cause celebre.

"It is possible that a court will say that the city ordinance does not discriminate on the basis of viewpoint or content," says Gene Policinski, executive director of the First Amendment Center at Vanderbilt University, in Nashville, Tenn. "But I think there's a better argument that this is political speech, and then there's a very high standard for when courts will allow [a town] to stop speech."

Formerly a railroad stop known as Bradford's Ordinary, Cary today is anything but. At nearly 130,000 people, Cary was among the fastest-growing areas in the US between 2005 and 2007, the Census Bureau reports, and is a perennial Top 10 winner on national "best places to live" lists. Natives have for years joked that the name is actually an acronym for "Containment Area for Relocated Yankees."

Indeed, more than 4,000 families from New York's Long Island alone have moved to Cary; only 30 percent of residents are native to North Carolina.

For many transplants, Cary is a suburban reserve, a sanctuary of northern NIMBY sensibilities set in a region where some natives flock on weekends to Big Ed's bric-a-brac breakfast joint in next- door Raleigh - a place replete with an actual Big Ed.

"I heard Cary described recently as the New Jersey of the South," says Bill Ferris, associate director of the Center for the Study of the American South at the University of North Carolina in Chapel Hill. "It's a unique kind of capsule of people who have come from outside the region and totally transformed the community."

Bowden, however, isn't from New Jersey. He's from North Carolina. His beef with the town stems from a road-widening project that he says results in flooding to his home during heavy rainstorms. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.