Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Goldman Sachs Rationalized Fraud

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Goldman Sachs Rationalized Fraud

Article excerpt

Goldman Sachs missed a big moral problem: Just because something isn't technically illegal doesn't mean it's right.

This month's announcement of the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC)'s securities-fraud civil suit against Goldman Sachs is a perfect example of what ails our society today - and why attempted regulatory fixes are in many ways analogous to rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic.

As Goldman Sachs representatives defend the firm at a Senate hearing today, the pertinent facts are largely uncontested.

Goldman Sachs helped the Paulson & Co. hedge fund, create and sell mortgage-based collateralized debt obligations (CDOs) that were designed to fail. This was done for the purpose of giving Paulson & Co. something perfect to bet against (via the purchase of credit default swaps). Being the full-service firm that it is, Goldman then helped sell these designed-to-fail CDOs to its very own clients.

Goldman collected millions of dollars in fees along the way: by helping to create the CDOs, by helping to sell the CDOs, and even by providing the necessary credit default swaps to Paulson & Co. As the housing market collapsed, the CDOs declined in value. Goldman's clients who bought into the CDOs lost approximately $1 billion in total.

Conversely, Paulson & Co. pocketed approximately $1 billion in total from the swaps it held.

Has Goldman committed securities fraud? Perhaps surprisingly, it's not altogether clear.

Securities law experts are split on the question. Goldman hasn't been accused of lying to anyone. Instead, the SEC is arguing that Goldman violated the law by omitting a material piece of information in its marketing of these securities: namely, that they were designed by another Goldman client (Paulson & Co.) for the specific purpose of losing value. Goldman counters by noting that it disclosed all of the securities' fundamentals, and that the investors purchasing these securities were just as capable of assessing their value and projected trajectory as was Paulson & Co. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.