Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

On Eve of World Cup, South Africa's 'Toilet Wars' Reveal Volatile Politics

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

On Eve of World Cup, South Africa's 'Toilet Wars' Reveal Volatile Politics

Article excerpt

Ahead of the South Africa World Cup, Cape Town has been gripped by its 'toilet wars.' After an opposition party erected shacks for the open air toilets in a shantytown, supports of the governing African National Congress tore them down, and did not replace them.

It is unlikely that the tens of thousands of foreign tourists flooding into South Africa for the World Cup, will take time to look into a rather embarrassing political dispute called "the toilet wars."

The dispute surrounds an effort by the city of Cape Town to provide toilets to the residents of Khayelitsha, a township, on its outskirts.

For decades, the residents of Khayelitsha have lived in tin shacks without proper sanitation, a situation that the ruling African National Congress promised to correct when it came to power in 1994.

But it took no action and last year, the opposition Democratic Alliance (DA) started putting toilets and plumbing next to each shack, with the understanding that the locals would build enclosures around them. About 7 percent of the locals either never bothered to or couldn't afford to build enclosures in the interim, and the DA- led local government eventually erected cheap tin shacks around the remainder of the toilets.

The members of the ANC's Youth League promptly tore the toilet shacks down, arguing they were insufficient and an insult to the residents, though they did not replace them.

The notion that toilets would become a matter of a rather violent struggle between two parties that fought on the same side against apartheid shows that politics in South Africa has taken a turn for the worse.

"The larger issue here is the constitutional right, and one of the most important rights, to dignity, and the way in which toilets were provided were an aberration of that right," says Aubrey Matshiqi, a senior political analyst at the Center for Policy Studies in Johannesburg. "The idea of having open-air toilets is an ANC idea, it was ANC that started building the toilets without enclosures. But both the ANC and the DA were guilty of letting the people of Khayelitsha go without services for too long."

Toilets, not roses

This much is certain: Neither party has come out smelling like roses. The Democratic Alliance - once seen as South Africa's best hope for an opposition party that could keep pressure on the ANC - has made Cape Town a showpiece for what it would like to do if given the chance to run South Africa. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.