Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Could Congress Shut Down YouTube with Internet-Blacklist Bill?

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Could Congress Shut Down YouTube with Internet-Blacklist Bill?

Article excerpt

The Combating Online Infringement and Counterfeits Act (COICA) passed a Senate committee last year. If it becomes law, this flawed attempt to curtail online copyright infringement could spell big trouble for Internet freedom.

A woman in China was sentenced last November to a year in prison for a satirical comment she made on Twitter, a social website the Chinese government had banned.

That same week, despite America's open criticism of government censorship in China and Iran, the United States Senate Judiciary Committee unanimously approved an Internet censorship bill of its own: the Combating Online Infringement and Counterfeits Act (COICA). Sen. Ron Wyden (D) of Oregon effectively blocked the bill from passing the full Senate, but it could re-emerge this year.

An Internet 'blacklist'

Thankfully, an especially aggressive provision of the legislation that would have authorized the Department of Justice to create a formal list of offending sites was stripped this past fall. But the amended bill still contains features that would enable a de facto public "blacklist." If it becomes law, COICA would not only be counterproductive to innovation and progress, but also diminish a constitutional right to free speech. Under this bill, entire websites could face serious repercussions if a court deemed copyright infringement "central to the activity of the website." [Editor's note: The original article failed to note a significant amendment to the bill this past fall and mischaracterized a potential penalty for websites.]

IN PICTURES: Top 10 countries that say Internet access is a basic right

President Obama claimed in an address to the United Nations in September that the United States would continue to support a "free and open Internet" and condemned current Internet restriction laws in other countries.

Federal Communications Commission Chairman Julius Genachowski also issued a statement following Mr. Obama's speech in which he claimed, "It is essential that we preserve the open Internet and stand firmly behind the right of all people to connect with one another and to exchange ideas freely."

If we don't think China should be able to outlaw Twitter, perhaps we shouldn't start banning websites in our own country. …

Author Advanced search


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.