Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Health Care Reform: House Marches toward Repeal Vote

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Health Care Reform: House Marches toward Repeal Vote

Article excerpt

Health care reform law is top target of the new GOP House majority. But critics say GOP leaders set aside their pledges of fiscal restraint and openness in pushing forward on vote to repeal it.

After promising a new era of openness and fiscal restraint, House Republicans veered from that standard on the first big vote of the new Congress: the repeal of health-care reform.

The powerful Rules Committee on Thursday vetted dozens of amendments, mainly from Democrats, but rejected all but one on party- line votes, eliminating the possibility of changes to legislation on the floor and leaving Democrats crying foul. [Editor's note: This paragraph has been changed from the original to account for an accepted amendment.]

GOP leaders also rejected calls to offset the cost of repeal, estimated by the Congressional Budget Office to be $230 billion over the next 10 years - more than double the spending cuts that the new GOP majority aims to pare from spending bills for fiscal year 2011. The CBO's preliminary estimate of the cost of repeal, released Thursday, also projects that repeal would leave 32 million more Americans uninsured.

The full House on Friday accepted that rule, setting the terms for next week's floor debate and ensuring the final vote will be a straight up or down one. The Friday vote in favor of those terms was 236 to 181, falling mainly along partisan lines.

Responding to criticism that this rule violates a key GOP pledge, Rep. David Drier (R) of California, who chairs the Rules Committee, said: "There is nothing to amend to the repeal bill. Either we're going to wipe the slate clean and start fresh or we're not."

"Once that slate is completely wiped clean, we will be ready for this open and collaborative process to develop the real solutions we promised," he added in Friday's floor debate on the rule.

In a break with past practice, the entire meeting was televised - fulfilling a GOP pledge to make all committee proceedings more accessible to the public.

"I promised a more open process. I didn't promise that every single bill was going to be an open bill," said Speaker John Boehner in his first press briefing on Thursday. "We went through a whole Congress, two years without one - without one open rule. As I said yesterday, there will be many open rules in this Congress, and just watch."

Democrats had hoped to force repeal proponents to take recorded votes on the most popular aspects of the new law, thus providing grist for campaign ads in the 2012 elections. These include ending the new ban on insurance companies discriminating on the basis of preexisting conditions, taking away the option for young adults up to the age of 26 to be covered by their parents' health insurance, and free annual wellness visits, tax breaks to help employers pay for coverage for employees, and a ban on lifetime caps on coverage. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.