Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Tim Pawlenty Takes Flak over GOP Debate. Was His Showing So Tragic?

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Tim Pawlenty Takes Flak over GOP Debate. Was His Showing So Tragic?

Article excerpt

Tim Pawlenty declined to be the attack dog against front-runner Mitt Romney in Monday's GOP presidential debate. Critics assailed him, but there are risks to going negative so early in the race.

It's the day after, and Tim Pawlenty is taking grief for not attacking front-runner Mitt Romney over health care during the New Hampshire presidential debate Monday night.

Mr. Pawlenty, the former two-term governor of Minnesota, had served up a clever slam against "Romneycare" the day before on "Fox News Sunday." Noting that Mr. Romney, the former governor of Massachusetts, had created the model for President Obama's health- care reform, he (or one of his advisers) invented a new term - "Obamneycare" - a sort of two-headed monster that forces Americans (and already, Massachusettsans) to purchase health insurance whether they want to or not.

But on Monday, when debate moderator John King asked Pawlenty "why Obamneycare," he demurred. He didn't look at Romney, and he chose instead to focus on what he did in Minnesota rather than go after the front-runner for the GOP nomination. It was all Mr. King could do to get Pawlenty even to utter the word "Obamneycare" again.

"Pawlenty's Manchester meltdown," the National Journal headline blared. "It was an opportunity missed - more painfully, an opportunity virtually everyone noticed, making the damage all the worse," the news site opined.

Really? Everyone played nice Monday night. No one went after the front-runner, and Romney himself was nice back. When given an opportunity to attack Pawlenty's recently unveiled economic plan, which posits a 5 percent growth rate many economists view as overly optimistic, Romney answered that Pawlenty has "the right instincts."

"The ideas Tim described, those are in the right wheelhouse," Romney said.

True, Romney and Pawlenty are not on an equal footing. Romney has established himself as the early front-runner, especially in the all- important New Hampshire primary. His fundraising is unparalleled in the Republican field. Pawlenty still polls in mid-single digits and can't hope to match Romney's money, his own campaign acknowledges.

But imagine if Pawlenty had gone negative, and been the only one to do so. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.