After considerable study and reflection, biology teacher Rodney
LeVake last year changed what he taught students about the origin of
life on earth.
Not only did he question the veracity of evolution, but the high
school teacher also introduced his class to "intelligent design
theory" - the notion that the complexity of the physical universe is
in itself proof of the existence of an intelligent creator.
By edict of the local school board, Mr. LeVake won't be teaching
biology this year.
This case, being fought out in a middle-size Minnesota city,
illustrates the tenacity of a 75-year dispute over what public
schools should teach about the genesis of human life. It also
indicates that, if anything, the fight has only intensified over the
past decade, with anti-evolution forces gaining some clear victories
in their efforts to cast doubt on Charles Darwin's widely accepted
The fight against evolution "is very much a grass-roots movement
and very much increasing," says Eugenie Scott, executive director of
the National Center for Science Education in Berkeley, Calif., a
group that battles to keep evolution at the center of science
teaching in America.
The most recent win for evolution opponents came last week in
Kansas, when the state Board of Education voted to remove any mention
of evolution from the science curriculum. Teaching evolution is not
prohibited, but standardized state tests will include no questions on
the topic - removing teacher motivation to explain the theory.
The decision has touched off a brouhaha not seen since the famous
"Scopes Monkey Trial" of 1925, when a Tennessee school teacher named
John Thomas Scopes stood trial for teaching what was then seen as the
"heretical" theory of evolution. Kansas Gov. Bill Graves, a moderate
Republican, has characterized the decision as an embarrassment "so
out of sync with reality" as to jeopardize the education board's
credibility. The American Civil Liberties Union and even TV's
"Science Guy," Bill Nye, have registered their disapproval.
A state by state battle
While Kansas is currently on the front lines of the fight, other
states have also changed how they present Darwin's theory in the
In Nebraska and New Mexico, evolution is still taught in
classrooms, but it is presented as a theory, not a fact. In Texas,
the state school board cut references to evolution from a standard
biology textbook. In Alabama, every biology textbook includes a
sticker that characterizes evolution as an unproven theory.
In other states - Washington, Ohio, Tennessee, and New Hampshire -
anti-evolution legislation was defeated. But the theory's defenders
warn that the most intense fights are at the local level, such as the
case in Faribault, Minn., over LeVake's teaching.
"They were afraid I'd turn my class into a Sunday School class,
but that was never my intention," says LeVake, who plans to appeal
his reassignment in court. "I just didn't want to teach evolution as
a dogmatic fact when there's a lot of recent evidence that points to
the opposite fact."
People involved in the debate cite several reasons for the recent
gains by evolution-theory foes.
For one, opponents have altered their strategy, no longer
insisting that schools abandon evolution in favor of creationism -
the doctrine that ascribes the origin of matter and life to acts of
creation by God. Instead, they aim to discredit evolution, arguing
that, in the interest of free scientific discourse, it should be
presented as just one theory about creation - and enlisting a corps
of like-minded scientists to help them. …