Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

No Easy Answers ; Technology Hasn't Proved to Be Education's Miracle Cure

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

No Easy Answers ; Technology Hasn't Proved to Be Education's Miracle Cure

Article excerpt

In the bad old days of the Soviet Empire, engineers who couldn't complete ill-conceived governmental projects were labeled "wreckers" and found themselves in prison camps.

Today, in the US, it's teachers' turn to take the hit for the lack of success that computers have brought to education.

Why haven't test scores gone up with the increased availability of computers? Why do computers with all the latest programs sit unused in classrooms, or at best serve only as word-processors or Internet searchers?

Those policymakers who giddily poured funding into technology as a cure for the ills of public education blame, among other scapegoats, stuck-in-the-mud teachers.

But offering faculty more extra-curricular seminars in the newest technological innovations is the wrong approach, Stanford professor Larry Cuban argues. In "Oversold and Underused" he writes, "By asking teachers to redouble their efforts, we take the spotlight off poorly designed hardware and software and inhospitable organizational structures that constrain teacher use."

In his interesting and readable study, Cuban notes other innovations that were to have transformed American education: film, radio, and TV. As we know, none of them did. Not for lack of trying, but because no matter how sophisticated or dazzling the technology, teaching boils down to communication. Electronic technology in the classroom is just another new gadget in a teacher's toolbox.

"Since the nineteenth century, chalk and blackboard, pens, pencils, and textbooks have proven themselves over and over again to be reliable and useful classroom technologies. Teachers added other innovations such as the overhead projector, the ditto machine (later the copying machine), and film projector (later the VCR) because they too proved reliable and useful. But most teachers continue to see the computer as an add-on rather than as a technology integral to their classroom ... instruction."

Cuban examines first-hand, rather than relying on self- reporting, how nursery and high school teachers in Silicon Valley actually use computers. Students more often learn (and use) computers at home than at school, and teachers use computers for writing and preparing lessons, not teaching. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.