Specials Explore Bible, Prayer and Healing ; Archaeologists Find Evidence of Old Testament World; Medicine Meets Spiritual Means

Article excerpt

Controversy over the Bible runs rampant. For a while, a small group of scholars calling themselves the Jesus Seminar won sensational headlines from magazines. That group (though some are highly respected scholars) claims little of the New Testament can be validated, very few of Jesus' words can be reliably attributed to him, and so on.

Now it's the Old Testament under the same revisionist fire. A new documentary attempts to put this controversy in context. Digging for the Truth: Archeology and the Bible (The History Channel, Dec. 17, 9- 11 p.m.) needs to be about two hours longer than it is. Too many loose ends are in need of tying up. And like so many documentaries dealing with complex subjects, it tends to oversimplify a variety of scholarly opinions into two camps.

Nevertheless, for anyone interested in the Bible, history, or archaeology, the film is riveting. It's shocking to find how politicized the Hebrew Scriptures have become. From the confines of academic speculation to the spotlight of political debate, the film shows, for example, that it may be impossible to appreciate the situation in Israel today without understanding how the Bible is being used by both sides to discredit the other.

A small group of Old Testament "minimalist" scholars has made sensational claims that Hellenistic Jews invented the stories of the Hebrew Scriptures to validate Jewish heritage. In this view, Moses didn't lead the Israelites out of Egypt - in fact, he never existed. Kings David and Solomon were likewise as mythological as Zeus.

Never mind the physical evidence of ancient Israel: Minimalist biblical scholars are not, as it turns out, archaeologists. Their claims are based on their interpretation of text.

"Minimalists read the text as myth," says William Dever, professor of Near Eastern archaeology and anthropology at the University of Arizona in Tucson and author of "What Did the Biblical Writers Know and When Did They Know It?" "But archaeologists engage every day with the reality of ancient Israel. It never occurs to us to doubt it existed."

It comes down to this: Those who support Palestinian claims to absolute sovereignty in the region are using the academic debate to say Israel has no claims to the Holy Land. And many of those who support Israel's claim say biblical tradition is backed by historical-archaeological findings of an ancient state, perhaps founded by King David.

The debate is hardly new. It's the result of a century of skepticism in biblical research. And it's true that the first archaeology in the Holy Land was undertaken by Christian ministers. Some of their findings have been reinterpreted. But archaeology now errs on the side of caution rather than faith.

"Archaeologists know how much they don't know," Dr. Dever says. "We are always finding new evidence.... We also know we have ideologies - but we can set them aside [in favor of] objectivity. There is an enormous consensus among archaeologists about so many issues."

Dever is not a theologian - or even religious. …


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.