Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Bay State Politics Roiled by Funding of Clean Elections ; Massachusetts Is Selling State Assets to Finance a Voter-Mandated Law - Will Lawmakers' Sofas Be Next?

Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor

Bay State Politics Roiled by Funding of Clean Elections ; Massachusetts Is Selling State Assets to Finance a Voter-Mandated Law - Will Lawmakers' Sofas Be Next?

Article excerpt

Want to buy a slightly-used station wagon, an old state armory, or perhaps the sofa where Massachusetts' legislative leader sits? Now's the time to bid.

There's a court-ordered fire sale of Massachusetts state property under way, the latest round in a nasty battle over how to fund the state's clean-election law.

What began in 1998 as a campaign-finance-reform victory has devolved into a constitutional standoff, pitting the powerful speaker of the House against the state's highest court.

By a 2-to-1 margin, voters approved public funding for candidates who pledge to limit their fundraising and spending. Massachusetts is now one of four states with such laws. Passing the referendum, though, proved to be the easy part.

Lawmakers, led by House Speaker Thomas Finneran, have refused to appropriate any of the $23 million that was to be set aside for candidates. At a time when the state faces a $2 billion budget gap, Mr. Finneran calls public campaign finance "nonsense," and the candidates who need it "pathetic." After candidates sued for the money, the state's Supreme Judicial Court ruled in January that the legislature had to either fund the clean-election law or repeal it.

Showdowns between branches of government over how best to spend money aren't unusual. Lawmakers and judges in a number of states - including neighboring New Hampshire, for instance - are locked in battles over how to fund public schools. But seldom does a legislature so brazenly ignore a court mandate, observers say.

"It's a dance between the courts and the legislature about how far they can push this," says Lawrence Friedman, a lecturer at Harvard Law School.

In the latest episode of the clash, a state high-court justice ruled candidates could demand the sale of state property to obtain the money candidates were promised. So last weekend, 13 station wagons and SUVs used by the state lottery commission were auctioned off for $176,800.

That still leaves tens of thousands more owed to four candidates who have already qualified for public financing. Having already obtained a minimum number of contributions, each has agreed to limit total campaign spending and put a $100 ceiling on individual donations. …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed

Oops!

An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.