Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor


Newspaper article The Christian Science Monitor


Article excerpt

Wandering orca highlights Canada's cultural complexities

Regarding Rondi Adamson's Sept. 4 Opinion piece, "Canada's whale of a dilemma": So many articles I have read about Luna seem content to focus only on the damage he does to boats, and what a "menace" he is. I was glad to see this article because it directly challenges the Mowachaht-Muchalaht First Nations' (MMFN) claim on Luna, and it is this "claim" that is the primary, if not only, reason why Luna is still alone and away from his family. There is so much political correctness these days, many people are afraid to call the First Nations on their mistakes when they make them (and in this case, they have made a big one).

The MMFN claims to honor nature and orca, but it is currently doing a great dishonor to Luna. Now is the ideal time for Luna to be reunited with his family. Let's hope with articles such as this one fueling public pressure, Canada's Department of Fisheries and Oceans will finally stand up against the MMFN and do what is right for Luna. Teresa Taggart Victoria, British Columbia

In human beings' interaction with the natural world, there is no relationship more special than the bond between predator and prey. Modern humans have - to a large degree - forgotten this, with our grocery stores where the consumer has little knowledge of the product he or she eats or drinks. Farmers and hunters, on the other hand, often share a bond with what they eat. There is no contradiction in revering what you kill - humans have done so since the dawn of time.

As for the statement that Luna/Tsuux-iit is a real whale and not a mythological one: For many native peoples, there is no difference between the mythological and the real - they are one and the same. As for the statement "We're sorry we stole your land," I can hardly find words to describe my outrage at such a falsity.

If it's true that "expressions of guilt - some sincere, some not - over past injustices have created an environment, at least in Canada, where anything short of concurrence with native ideas is seen as arrogance," then why is there so much prejudice and injustice against the First Nations? …

Search by... Author
Show... All Results Primary Sources Peer-reviewed


An unknown error has occurred. Please click the button below to reload the page. If the problem persists, please try again in a little while.